As reported in earlier posts in this forum and others, the hobby of collecting tokens is relatively young. I'm talking about trade tokens ("Good Fors") here, as opposed to say, Hard Times or Civil War tokens. As such, there has been no established market such as there is for coins, so no price guide is accurate. Also, compared to coins, trade tokens are pretty scarce in general, and collectors of them are even more scarce. The only "real" way to determine the price of a token is to actually sell it - a willing buyer and a willing seller. Generalizations about pricing is the best you can do at this point - for instance an "unlisted" Idaho token will sell for several times what an "unlisted" Indiana token will bring (Supply and Demand). Online auctions have facilitated matching a seller with a buyer, but there is a many-decade long tradition of mail bid sales from the few token dealers that exist or in the publications of national and regional token collecting organizations.
Sorry to say that you can't just go to
www.tokenvalues.com (not a real site) and look up your tokens.
John in ID