1965 Silver?? Quarter

[JRW276]

I have been metal detecting and collecting coins for years and came across a strange coin. It is a 1965 U.S. Quarter that looks and feels silver. It is in rough shape and is very tarnished. Looks and sounds just like every other silver quarter I have found yet I thought they stopped making them in 1964. The edge is one color (silver) and the coins has that distinctive silver sound to it. Coin weighs 6.19 grams. Any one ever hear of one of these and if so is it valuable??

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Minelab PRO-FIND 35 Waterproof Pinpointer Metal Detector for Experts with Tone ID & Adjustable Sensitivity - Grab it through Amazon!

[antique man]

Looks like you might have something worth holding to to, JRW. According to my error book a normal quarter weighs 5.67 grams, and the silver quarter weighs about 6.25 grams, so your quarter is only a couple grams less, probably from the wear.
You may want to send it to PCGS to get it certified. If it is a 1965 silver quarter it can be worth $2,500.

Good luck.

-Braden
Age 12

 

[Breezie]

Looks like you might have something worth holding to to, JRW. According to my error book a normal quarter weighs 5.67 grams, and the silver quarter weighs about 6.25 grams, so your quarter is only a couple grams less, probably from the wear.
You may want to send it to PCGS to get it certified. If it is a 1965 silver quarter it can be worth $2,500.

Good luck.

-Braden
Age 12

JRW & Braden, WELCOME to the forum! Braden, I'm very impressed with your knowledge and presentation of your reply for your age.

I'm not the coin person, so until the coin experts come alone, JRW, you might want to take Braden's advice and have an expert see it in person.

Neat find
Breezie

 

[nhbenz]

Welcome to TreasureNet.
Your quarter appears to be void of any reeding on the edge; am I seeing that right?
I also wondered if I'm seeing a bit of crookedness to the lettering where it says "in God we trust"?
Although I find that this could be a rare (but recorded) silver planchet error, considering the overall crude appearances I'm more inclined to think this is a counterfeit. But that being said, there are much more knowledgable coin-folks here and I hope that I'm proven wrong.

 

[Breezie]

Welcome to TreasureNet.
Your quarter appears to be void of an reeding on the edge; am I seeing that right?
I also wondered if I'm seeing a bit of crookedness to the lettering where it says "in God we trust"?
Although I find that this could be a rare (but recorded) silver planchette error, considering the overall crude appearances I'm more inclined to think this is a counterfeit. But that bing said, there are much more knowledgable coin-folks here and I hope that I'm proven wrong.

Good eye Benz! With no reeding on the edges, that is a big red flag!


Breezie

 

[JRW276]

There is a small amount of reeding left (other side of coin) on it but the coin is in rough shape. It looks like it may have been cut into which leads me to believe it is silver. (Wish it was in better shape). I will take some more photos where you can see the worn reeding and put them up.

 

[nhbenz]

A photo of the back too may help... I'm just curious about the detail on it.

 

[cudamark]

An acid test will tell you if it's silver or not.

 

[GatorBoy]

Something looks odd about the metal itself to me.. Including the thickness... did you try swinging a magnet over it?

 

[dollydazed]

your coin is to heavy to be a clad 1965 5.67 grams. 1932-64 6.25 grams. pretty close with the wear on your coin. I would have it looked at and tested for silver
could be a great find

 

[JRW276]

Sorry to take so long loading up new photos. Snow in New England is keeping us busy!! Here is the best photo I could get of the reverse side and the wore down reeding on the side. Coin is in rough shape for sure. Does not react with magnet at all.

 

[FreeBirdTim]

Since it's in rough condition, you could try to clean it a little bit. Try cleaning just the edge of the coin with silver polish or a silver polishing cloth. If the cloth you use turns black, then it's silver. No black on the cloth, then it's a clad coin. That would be lot less damaging than testing it with acid.

 

[antique man]

Do not clean it. It will decrease the value

 

[bigfoot1]

if you are intending to stay in the hobby it is a great idea to purchase a test kit(amazon has good deals).It is hard when you dont know.a local jewler can test for free.dont worry about damage...there wont be any...they dont put the acid directly on the coin.The advice to have it looked at by a numismatist(coin dude)is solid.good luck and welcome

 

[Diggin-N-Dumps]

Looks like its been tumbling in a Dryer for a while..looking forward to see how this ends!

 

[antique man]

Oh btw you should probably hill your coins by the edges and not touch the front or back of the coin. (Wouldn't wanna get fingerprints on it.)

 

[antique man]

Oops meant hold

 

[xrunndonex]

Is you're scale accurate? Its in the middle of clad and silver. Makes me think is a silver plated clad quarter.

 

[FreeBirdTim]

"Do not clean it. It will decrease the value"

Cleaning a very small part of the edge will not decrease it's value. In that condition, not much he does to it is going to significantly decrease it's value. It would also resolve this issue ASAP.

 

[FreeBirdTim]

"You may want to send it to PCGS to get it certified. If it is a 1965 silver quarter it can be worth $2,500."

Not a bad idea, but it will cost $40 minimum to grade it. He's going to feel pretty silly if he spends $40 to grade a clad 1965 quarter in rough condition!