button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research (PICS NOW ADDED)

[bigcreekdad]

Still in search of my first silver, I hit an old park yesterday for an hour or so before it got hot. The park was where there were evidence of remains of ramparts of a British fort in the late 1700's. IN any case, I've previously found clad, but no silver or anything of interest. However, this hunt produced at 8"+ what looks like an old button. It is quite corroded, but you can make out the number "24" on it. I tried a pic with my son's cheap camera, but it wasn't worth posting. My camera is up at my cabin, so I'll try again when I get it.

Curiosity got me to doing some web surfing about military buttons. After several web hunts, I found a site that indicated that sometime after 1750 the British required regimental numbers to be on buttons of uniforms. Making the assumption that this button might come from the uniform of a member of the British 24th Regiment, I googled it and found that the British 24th regiment was indeed in North America in the 1700's. Adding the word "Ohio" to the google I found a rather long treatise of the history of the battles between the US and Britain between the War of Independence and the War of 1812. After 30 minutes of scanning this long piece, I came upon proof that the 24th was indeed in this specific county I was hunting in, even naming one of the Majors.

I thought MD'ing for me was all about coins.......boy was I wrong. This is cool stuff!!

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Minelab PRO-FIND 35 Waterproof Pinpointer Metal Detector for Experts with Tone ID & Adjustable Sensitivity - Grab it through Amazon!

[Old River]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

The research is where all the fun is. Congrats....

 

[Woodland Detectors]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

Nice buddy!
I'm hoping that button is the one I'm thinking about!

It's good to see your having fun!!

Mike

 

[Iron Patch]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

You need to post a picture of both sides. That button is either very good or maybe not so good. My fingers are crossed for you.

http://forum.treasurenet.com/index.php/topic,123226.0.html

 

[bigcreekdad]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

What would make it good vs. not so good? It's in horrible shape, but based on my research, I think it's the real deal. I will try to get a pic though.

 

[Iron Patch]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

What would make it good vs. not so good? It's in horrible shape, but based on my research, I think it's the real deal. I will try to get a pic though.

Real vs a reproduction. Condition doesn't mean anything and the only way to know is to post some decent pictures of both sides.

Just so you know the majority found in similar context end of being modern, but if the park has history back to the 1700s it is possible. I found a CT copper at a park here among the modern finds so you never know.

 

[ivan salis]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

seems you might have a bit of local history in your hands --lol--yep its not all only about coins or silver and gold items --

 

[bigcreekdad]

trying pics

here goes

 

[ivan salis]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

that looks like it has some serious age on it , condition wize --i;d think it real --unless local colonail re enactors use the park area -- if the areas history leans to british 24th troops being in that area - i think you got a winner !

 

[Iron Patch]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

Yep, that's a good one! You're definitely going to want to seal it because it won't take too long before it will dry up and crack into pieces. There's obviously already a bad crack you have to be concerned about.

 

[Kirk PA]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

That is definitely a Colonial keeper in my books. Wow, and to have been found in 1700s Ohio! Nice ID, Patch.

Kirk

 

[hogge]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

That is not a repro! Nice find!

 

[civilman1]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

Nice one.....It's as real as real can get.Congrat's

 

[The Patriot]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

Congrats...it is what it is!! like IP says seal that sucker or over time you'll lose it all together

 

[bigcreekdad]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

How do I seal it?

 

[Iron Patch]

Re: button found......no pic yet, but some interesting research

How do I seal it?

What I do is paint on a coat of water-based urethane (clear coat) and wipe. First I do the back and sides, let dry, then do the face. By using a lint free cloth and wiping right away it makes the coat very then. If you leave it painted on without a wiping it will be thick and glossy. The urethane will sink in the cracks making it stable for the future. Just try it on a few buttons you don't care about, and ask any questions beforehand.

 

[Iron Patch]

Here's a shot of the urethane I use, and a few examples of buttons sealed with it. Even with the bright light the buttons do not have much shine... (and less in person) which is something you try to limit for a pewter button. A clear coat on pitting is not a great mix, but if done right it shouldn't be too bad, and something definitely has to be done with your find. Wax could be an option, and I have a lot of experience using it too, but prefer the urethane.

There is one other factor to consider too... and that's the weak detail. Sometimes coating something that is just barely there can make the detail slightly worse. (because the light portions around the number 24 could get slightly darker and blend with the number) One way to test what it might look like is to wet the button, then pat dry and see what it looks like. (wet but with the excess water gone) Again, I think you will be ok and probably have it looking very close to what it is now if you do it right.

 

[HEAVYMETALNUT]

cool pewter button congrats! i used hair spray on my revolutionary war USA continental army button.are you in upstate ny on lake champlain by any chance?

 

[bigcreekdad]

I am in Ohio