is metal detecting at my local park illegal?

[gleaner1]

sorry

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Upgraded Night Vision Monocular Digital Infrared Monocular Telescope for 100% Darkness with 8X Zoom - Grab it through Amazon!

[gleaner1]

.

 

[Tom_in_CA]

..... but just ask the police to be sure. after all, if you don't know, how are we to know? .....

Gleaner, no, a person does not need to ask the police, (or parks dept, or city-hall clerk, or school admin, or ..... whomever), "to be sure". There is another way to know: Look it up for oneself.

City muni codes, laws, rules, regulations, ordinances, are all public knowledge, in print, somewhere, somehow. If the city does not have a website with those things listed, then at least on the front desk at city hall, for public viewing. Because legally, it has to be available to view, somewhere. Some bigger cities are now subscribing to this service, for instance:

State Listing - Municipal Code Corporation

Once you look it up for yourself, and see nothing that says "no metal detecting", well then gee, I guess that answers the question

You may ask: "well that's time consuming, and my city (or county or whatever) doesn't have it out in binder form at the front desk, etc..., so WHY NOT just ask a cop, or gardener, or clerk?" Here's the answer: Because all too often, even if you phrase the question carefully to say "Is there any rules against metal detectors in the park?" (thinking that would put the burden of proof on them to PRODUCE or CITE such an actual specific rule), yet it can backfire. There are examples I've heard where they simply say "no you can't" (as if you'd just asked their permission, and not asked if there is a "rule"). And if you object and say "but where is that written?", guess who's going to win that debate? They can just morph something else to apply to your question (the dreaded alteration, defacing, and digging type stuff), and do you really think you're going to win that debate? Mind you, that very person you're asking, perhaps NEVER would have given the matter a moment's thought (till you asked).

That's not to say that sometimes the carefully worded question does go in the md'rs favor, and they might say "no, I don't see anything addressing the subject of metal detectors". I'm not saying that might not happen too. But for me, I wouldn't take that chance, and will look it up for myself.

 

[gleaner1]

In my neck of the woods, I have had NYS troopers, city police, county sherriff, and NYS park police drive up or walk up and ask "What the frik ya doin?" I say "Well Occifer, I'm lookin for old coins and such". 99.9 percent of the time, they leave. Sometimes they ask for my permit, which I have of course. Now the hard part. Sometimes they ask "Ya find anything good?". Now I have to lie to the police.

 

[MichiganMan]

I like the idea of practicing at home. After all, if you treat others' property as you treat your own, or, Love others' property as you love your own, then you have fulfilled the Golden Rule.

 

[Charlie P. (NY)]

Hello! I live in clare michigan is it illegal to dig holes when metal detecting there?


Thanks

How would most of us know your local ordinances? What did they say when you called the city Parks Department? (989) 386-4508. You shouldn't need the area code as it is a local call for YOU.

Or you can e-mail them:

Contact Us - The City of Clare

 

[gleaner1]

Sorry Charlie.......

 

[Trackerman]

Depends on the park and the ahole working there sometimes