My Holy Grail would probably make some of you laugh. I have always wanted to find anything from the 1700's or earlier. But I need to someday find a hammered silver coin. I see everyone on here finding them and I envy all of you who do. I don't think they are around here but I will still find one someday and then my life will be complete. lol, okay its not that dramatic but I really want to find one.
I sold the card for $1500.00 and just about a month later the card was worth $15k. I have kicked myself in the ass ever since.
Breaking into the 1700's club, any coin from that period would be on my list. Living in Ohio there is a slim chance for the 1700's and almost no chance for the 1600's.
Holy grail in my part of the world (alberta Canada) would be a hudsons bay trade ax. Not unheard of to find but danged rare.