Last year, I bought a box of junk from a coin dealer, and in the bottom of the box was a handful of plated IH cents, very much like the one you have.
These coins were authentic coins that had been plated and polished, and sold as a subscription service. You've seen the ads..."Buy these 110 year old Indian Head Cents...never to be minted again...just $9.99 plus $6.99 shipping. Cancel any time. Offer strictly limited to 10 offers per person."