I'd say u did have great success with your first box of nickels. That buffalo looks like its in amazing MS condition. Seems like a lot of great buffalo finds lately in amazing high grade condition. Btw, its kinda strange that I had very similar success with my last box of nickels too - I found a '36 buffalo and two silver nickels also. But my buffalo wasn't anywhere near as nice as the one u found. That was my best nickel box in some time.
Glad u had such great success starting out. Hope u have continued success. HH!
That is a fantastic buffalo!! I'd say about AU55, and those gorgeous war nicks are pretty sharp too! Congrats on your awesome finds, happy for you! I'm glad I encouraged you to broaden your horizon and to try nickels, means a lot to me.
Again, congrats, HH!
That is a good looking Buffalo....I found a Buffalo and 2 silver yesterday too. Those are way better then the three I found. I only did $20 of BWRs though. It was a new bank that I will be going back to. $20 in dimes produced a '57 Roosevelt also.