Wow, that is an impressive score, but I can't say I would have paid that much. I pay whatever someone asks. The reason I do this is simple. I do not own a store. I pick up items at garage sales. Most of the garage sales I go to I don't buy anything. Maybe 10% or 15% of the sales I go to I buy something. Usually, the item I buy does not make me much. So, it is a very rare sale that I make a large amount of money. I also work part time driving around a guy for $12 an hour. On the days we work, we work 10 or 12 hours a day, so my take home after taxes is around $100. Obviously, that job is really easy. There are many times when I go to sales, drive around all day, and I don't buy anything. Actually, buying at sales is more work than just driving around the guy all day, and I might make nothing. So, to make up for the days I make nothing, I need to have those days in which I make a good score. Also, garage sales are seasonal and just 2 days a week, you simply do not have much time to find items. In addition to this, going to sales requires gas and wear on tear on your vehicle, all of this needs to be factored in. Also, unless you have someone you know that will pay you full retail price or full melt value on something, you will be forced to pay ebay and paypal fees, all of which eats into your profits. I don't know of anyone, with the exception of store owners(which requires additional capital), that makes a good living picking. It is always just extra money. I know, one out of a million people will find that old rare item that is worth a fortune, but most will not. Therefore, whenever I can make a good score, I will. As long as both parties walk away happy, I am fine with that. I will not spend 1,000 dollars to make 100 dollars. With all the time and work involved with that, it is far easier for me just to drive the guy around, and I won't have to spend any money to do so. What you did was very kind. What you paid for the jewelry shows your class and integrity, and I can respect that. But, for me, there has to be some real money in the game, or I just do not care. My job is not to inform people at garage sales that they priced their items too low.