What's new

Coinstar has been hot lately and today it literally turned into a GOLD MINE

CJ9

Hero Member
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
619
Reaction score
1,902
Golden Thread
0
Location
NYC area
Primary Interest:
Other
I have been recently finding a lot of silver at one particular Stop & Shop Coinstar that is close to my home, and today was the pinnacle of it all - I found a Swiss 20 Franc gold piece from 1922 (0.1867oz of gold). Never in my imagination did I ever think that I would find gold in a Coinstar, but as we have seen so many times on here, you never know. I do remember that someone here about a year or 2 ago found the 1926 gold sesquicentennial coin - which blew my mind as there were so few of them actually minted - so it does happen on occasion. These finds have made up for the slim pickings I have had CRHing lately (wonder if the recent move of silver to $100 a month or so ago either brought out more CRHers or people wised up and started looking through their coins before they rolled them and went to the bank.

coinstar 3-20.webp
coinstar 3-20a.webp
coinstar 3-20b.webp


In addition to the gold piece there were 2 silver quarters, 3FDR dimes, 1 merc, and a 1953 Canadian 80% silver. There was also $2.10 in Canadian clad, $2.65 from Barbados, 1.10 Swiss francs, 15 British pence (including two 1/2p coins), as well as some other foreign coins. The only US "clad" were 2 pennies.

On 3/7, I went to the same Stop & Shop and pulled this out of the Coinstar:

Coinstar 3-7.webp


1 40% half, 4 90% silver quarters, 1 90% silver proof quarter (North Carolina 2001), 3 FDR, and 1 1951 KG VI 80% Canadian dime. There was also 55c in Canadian clad. Oddly enough, no US clad at all.

The next day (3/8), I went into the same Stop & Shop and found this:

coinstar 3-8.webp


another silver quarter, 1 nice merc from 1945 and 1 FDR dime. This time there was some US clad.


Thanks for looking
 
I have been recently finding a lot of silver at one particular Stop & Shop Coinstar that is close to my home, and today was the pinnacle of it all - I found a Swiss 20 Franc gold piece from 1922 (0.1867oz of gold). Never in my imagination did I ever think that I would find gold in a Coinstar, but as we have seen so many times on here, you never know. I do remember that someone here about a year or 2 ago found the 1926 gold sesquicentennial coin - which blew my mind as there were so few of them actually minted - so it does happen on occasion. These finds have made up for the slim pickings I have had CRHing lately (wonder if the recent move of silver to $100 a month or so ago either brought out more CRHers or people wised up and started looking through their coins before they rolled them and went to the bank.

View attachment 2248086View attachment 2248087View attachment 2248088

In addition to the gold piece there were 2 silver quarters, 3FDR dimes, 1 merc, and a 1953 Canadian 80% silver. There was also $2.10 in Canadian clad, $2.65 from Barbados, 1.10 Swiss francs, 15 British pence (including two 1/2p coins), as well as some other foreign coins. The only US "clad" were 2 pennies.

On 3/7, I went to the same Stop & Shop and pulled this out of the Coinstar:

View attachment 2248089

1 40% half, 4 90% silver quarters, 1 90% silver proof quarter (North Carolina 2001), 3 FDR, and 1 1951 KG VI 80% Canadian dime. There was also 55c in Canadian clad. Oddly enough, no US clad at all.

The next day (3/8), I went into the same Stop & Shop and found this:

View attachment 2248090

another silver quarter, 1 nice merc from 1945 and 1 FDR dime. This time there was some US clad.


Thanks for looking
Is there a banner for coinstar finds? That is incredible!!!
 
That would be a fantastic find.... if it's genuine. I would just caution that it's a highly targeted coin for (often high quality) replicas and fakes. The colour of yours doesn't look great, I have to say.

I sure hope it's the real deal, but could we please see a picture of the obverse at the same quality level as your reverse picture, a close up of the stars on the edge, and an exact weight if you are able to provide it?
 
This provides a good amount of information on what to look for in a forgery.

How to Detect Counterfeits at All Times. Part 1: Swiss Vreneli Coins | MünzenWoche https://share.google/A6B6noKLoXtecLaCO

Congratulations on your fabulous streak of finds lately.
 
That would be a fantastic find.... if it's genuine. I would just caution that it's a highly targeted coin for (often high quality) replicas and fakes. The colour of yours doesn't look great, I have to say.

I sure hope it's the real deal, but could we please see a picture of the obverse at the same quality level as your reverse picture, a close up of the stars on the edge, and an exact weight if you are able to provide it?
Getting the true color for gold with indoor lighting, and even cameras is a crap shoot.
I've taken pictures of gold, looked at the picture and it's nothing like what the gold looks like.
But the details in the picture is what we should be looking for.
 
Last edited:
That would be a fantastic find.... if it's genuine. I would just caution that it's a highly targeted coin for (often high quality) replicas and fakes. The colour of yours doesn't look great, I have to say.

I sure hope it's the real deal, but could we please see a picture of the obverse at the same quality level as your reverse picture, a close up of the stars on the edge, and an exact weight if you are able to provide it?
thanks, and here are some up-close pictures. Note that I have overhead lights in the room that I am in
Also, the coin is not magnetic for what that is worth
there are stars around the edge of the coin


gold coin 3-20.webp
gold coin 3-20a.webp
 
thanks, and here are some up-close pictures. Note that I have overhead lights in the room that I am in
Also, the coin is not magnetic for what that is worth
there are stars around the edge of the coin


View attachment 2248111View attachment 2248112
Just curious, have you weighed your coin to see if it is the same weight listed? That is a beauty.
 
Thanks for the better picture. I can't say for sure, but I am suspicious. Although the obverse doesn't exhibit any of the features detailed in the article linked by @pepperj for fakes, those are not the only distinguishers for non-authentic coins. This one pictured below doesn't have those features either, but it's not a fake as such in the sense of being intended to deceive.

Replica1.webp


It's a high quality gold-plated replica intended as a souvenir, or as a 'space-filler' for collectors and available on Etsy and elsewhere for about £20. However, what it does have is a flaw on Vreneli's neck below the ear, which is not on present on authentic examples.

Genuine.webp


There appears to be a die flaw in a similar area on your example. It's not in exactly the same position but abnormal raised dots or other defects in the neck area are known die characteristics for these kinds of replicas.

An exact weight will be the clincher for authenticity.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the better picture. I can't say for sure, but I am suspicious. Although the obverse doesn't exhibit any of the features detailed in the article linked by @pepperj for fakes, those are not the only distinguishers for non-authentic coins. This one pictured below doesn't have those features either, but it's not a fake as such in the sense of being intended to deceive.

View attachment 2248121

It's a high quality gold-plated replica intended as a souvenir, or as a 'space-filler' for collectors and available on Etsy and elsewhere for about £20. However, what it does have is a flaw on Vreneli's neck below the ear, which is not on present on authentic examples.

View attachment 2248124

There appears to be a die flaw in a similar area on your example. It's not in exactly the same position but abnormal raised dots or other defects in the neck area are known die characteristics for these kinds of replicas.

An exact weight will be the clincher for authenticity.
assuming the dimensions check out as well.
 
Thanks for the better picture. I can't say for sure, but I am suspicious. Although the obverse doesn't exhibit any of the features detailed in the article linked by @pepperj for fakes, those are not the only distinguishers for non-authentic coins. This one pictured below doesn't have those features either, but it's not a fake as such in the sense of being intended to deceive.

View attachment 2248121

It's a high quality gold-plated replica intended as a souvenir, or as a 'space-filler' for collectors and available on Etsy and elsewhere for about £20. However, what it does have is a flaw on Vreneli's neck below the ear, which is not on present on authentic examples.

View attachment 2248124

There appears to be a die flaw in a similar area on your example. It's not in exactly the same position but abnormal raised dots or other defects in the neck area are known die characteristics for these kinds of replicas.

An exact weight will be the clincher for authenticity.
Red-Coat, you are amazing...fascinating stuff...I hope you are wrong for CJ9's sake...
 
...I found a Swiss 20 Franc gold piece from 1922 (0.1867oz of gold)...In addition to the gold piece there were 2 silver quarters, 3FDR dimes, 1 merc, and a 1953 Canadian 80% silver. There was also $2.10 in Canadian clad, $2.65 from Barbados, 1.10 Swiss francs, 15 British pence (including two 1/2p coins), as well as some other foreign coins. The only US "clad" were 2 pennies....1 40% half, 4 90% silver quarters, 1 90% silver proof quarter (North Carolina 2001), 3 FDR, and 1 1951 KG VI 80% Canadian dime. There was also 55c in Canadian clad...another silver quarter, 1 nice merc from 1945 and 1 FDR dime...
t_r.gif
tn_coinstar.gif
t_l.gif

..: UNBELIEVABLE RECOVERIES :..
Here is my CoinStar Surfing Log!​
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom