I'm not new to metal detecting, but was out of it for a number of years. Got all wrapped up in mountain biking and had little time for anything else. A couple of years ago I sold my detectors at a yard sale.
This year I really got the urge to get back into it. I had my eye set on the Garrett GTA1350, as I had two Garretts in the past. When I started reading about the Ace, I decided to save some money and go with it.
I used it daily for the entire month of September and I think I got pretty good with it. Being in Canada, the ID for coins is all wrong, but that was a problem with my old 1000 too. I found a school that had not been hunted and I pulled 105 coins out of the yard on one side. I was meticulous to make sure I covered it all, and I only notched out the first 2 bars. I dug more than just the belltones. I thought 105 coins was pretty good.
A week ago I bought a Tesoro Tejon because of the outstanding reviews I read. I felt that since the oldest coin I found at that school was a 1944 (and the school was built in 1928) that the lack of depth may be depriving me of the old coins I'm after. So I went back to that school, with about 1/2 hour of experience on the Tejon, and retraced my steps exactly. Started in the same place, same grid etc. I found 52 more coins, with a larger percentage of dimes, and nickels. I was finding dimes and nickels with the Ace, but it missed a lot, including a 1942. Remember, this was while I was (am) still learning the Tejon.
Also, with the Ace, I found the need to buy a pinpointer as I could get close, but never exact. With the Tejon, I rarely use it, and I think I can now practice the art of plucking out coins with a probe.
So I would conclude that the Ace is probably the best detector in that price range, and should be the detector of choice for someone just getting into the hobby. For me, I'll take my Tesoro every time, as I don't have confidence in the Ace to be thorough enough, and I find machines with TID to just be a distraction.
Just my opinion,
Dan