Sounds like the restaurant I worked in years ago as a prep cook.Before the place opened,a reporter was there.She was interviewing the manager for a story about the place.He told her that they made all their own salad dressings.Me being the prep cook said dressings would of been my responsibility to make.One problem being is that I was never given any recipes to make any dressings so it was a lie.
And therein lies the lie within the truth. Your manager didn't lie, he just had a different definition of what MAKE means. LOL Just like Diggers might have a different definition for a "find," and eBay sellers have a specific definition for "unsearched roll!" (meaning YOU haven't searched it, yet. *cracks up*)
Is it a live find? Is it intended to look like they're finding item after item after item (when it's actually 3 items over a week of hunting?) Is a "find" a "find" if they found it last time, but put it into the ground this time? Is a find a find, if they found it last year, and put it into the ground this time? Is a find a find, if someone on the crew finds it, and one of the stars comes over and does the weenie wiggle dance over having "discovered history!"
For us, we probably define "find" as "YOU" found it, and it was on the HUNT you're describing! I think about the person who posted the friend's find of the Draped Bust Dollar... totally banner worthy, but declined to have it show up, because HE didn't "find" the coin... Was it found? yes, but not by him. He felt that it was unethical to claim otherwise. And THAT is probably A reason (not the only one, for sure) why Diggers MAY feel off to people. It's a matter of definitions not aligning.
For me, I'd rather scour youtube for videos, than watch someone act (possibly OVER-act) getting excited over finding a dirt clod covered 1901 IHP. The first wheatie you found was probably super exciting... do you dance when you find a 1957 Wheatie laying on the grass, now? Probably not. Is it still fun? yes, but not to the same degree. These guys are acting, just a tad.

And THAT is performance art. There's nothing wrong with acting... but I think they sort-of bill it as "legit." and that's where many of us just roll our eyes.
Skippy