What's new

First Buffalo Nickel...is it three-legged? Now with pictures added!

Turtleman

Full Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2007
Messages
156
Reaction score
3
Golden Thread
0
Location
NW PA
Detector(s) used
Ace 250 and Minelab Explorer II
I had about an hour after my class left out to hit a park before my wife and children got home from a meeting. The park dates to the 1910's. I have searched it about a half dozen times prior to today. I have found a lot of clad and a silver pendant in the park. I have also found 7 wheat pennies.
Today, right before I had to leave the park, I got a mixture of silver and nickel signals near a large (100+ years old) tree. The tree is surrounded by modern picnic tables. I dug and found an old, rusted out nail. I scanned the hole again and got another signal then pulled a bottle cap from the hole. I scanned again and got a good silver signal. I used my digger to clear out more dirt and there in the dirt was an Indian head/buffalo nickel-my first. It was about 4 inches down. I scanned and there were no more signals. I also found a wheat penny at the base of the tree under a large root. These two coins were about two feet from each other.
I brought the coins home and ran some water over them. The wheat penny is quite worn and I still can't make out the date due to dirt that is still clinging like dry concrete to it. However, I could see quickly that the nickel was a 1937. What I can't fully tell yet is whether it has three or four legs. I also can't quite determine if the mint is a D or an S (if it is an S I know it has four legs.) There is still some dirt clinging to it and I don't want to scratch the coin up. Does anyone have a good method for cleaning copper nickels that will not cause their value to decline? The coin seems to be in good shape-I can see the pleats in the feathers on the Indian's headdress and the date is bold. The buffalo side appears to be deeply pressed and quite recessed.
I will post a picture when it is cleaned.
Also, any tips on cleaning wheat pennies? And any suggestions why my detector showed a strong silver signal/$1 when the nickel is mostly copper?
I will go back to the spot again soon as I was getting a number of silver and nickel signals all around the tree but time ran out. By the way, all of the wheats I have found in this park have been 1910's-20's. Hopefully silver is out there still.
Thanks, in advance, for any info. on cleaning the coins.
Turtleman
 
Upvote 0
Doyboy and others,
So far I haven't done anything to the coin except run water over it to get the date. I know polishing the coin and other sorts of cleaning methods devalue the coin. What do you do if you want to sell a coin to a dealer? Do you just let it like it is with some dirt still on it and let the dealer decide how to clean it up or do you try something on your own? Some offered the advice to soak old coins-my question is in what solution? Does soaking them in olive oil designate an attempt to clean them and thus devalue the coins?
By the way, hopefully I will get out later today to check for the rest of the herd in that area. I'll keep everyone posted.
Turtleman
 
Dan i think your Buffaloes look great! And Musclecar we would like to see your Barber. We all know not to clean a suspected valuable coin, but i do the same thing to my nickels that are not valuable, they look so much better than being all rusty looking. HH Coinman66
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom