What's new

Found a large nickel hoard on 8/22

CJ9

Hero Member
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
619
Reaction score
1,902
Golden Thread
0
Location
NYC area
Primary Interest:
Other
On Friday (8/22) I went into a bank that is very close to where I live. They all know me in there and know I collect. They all the CWR nickels and dimes that they can (sometimes they hold some back because that is all they have). The only stipulation is that I don't dump any of the rolls back on them. So on Friday I had to do some other banking and the one teller had $20 in CWR nickels that she gave me. I looked at them at home and within those rolls I found 7 war nickels and a 1937 buffalo. One of the rolls was marked 1969D and that is what they all were.

So having found that, I went back and the second teller was also there. So then I got an additional $40 in nickels (I told them I found stuff - they often ask what I have found - and I even told them what to look for - but they have no interest in looking or collecting). 4 of those rolls ($8) were marked with certain years (1968, 1972, etc), so I knew those were duds, but the remaining $32 were loaded with war nickels.

I went back a third time thinking that there may be some other denominations that this person may have brought in. Well, out came more nickels, and I got another $28 (I was able to dump $28 of the ones I had before because that was all they had), and those were the same - lots of war nickels, a few buffaloes, and even 3 Liberty nickels that are well worn (although 1 was 1899, so it was good to get back into the 1800s club - albeit, barely). They said that the person brought in quarters, so I took $100 of those (I never search quarters), but there was nothing - actually many of the rolls were short, so I wound up with $94 - just chalk that up to the cost of doing business.

So all-in, having looked at $88 in nickels in total ($78 if you take out the rolls that were marked with a certain date, which were as advertised), the finds were:

116 war nickels:
1942P: 12
1942S: 9
1943P: 27
1943D: 1
1943S: 7
1944P: 12
1944D: 4
1944S: 7
1945P: 15
1945D: 7
1945S: 15

Buffaloes: 1936, 1937 (x2), 2 dateless
Liberty: 1899, 1902, 1903

Thanks for looking
Nickels 8-22.webp
Nickels 8-22a.webp
Nickels 8-22b.webp
 
Upvote 0
Each war nickel contains 35% silver. The pure silver content in a single war nickel is approximately 0.05626 troy ounces. 116 nickles x 0.05626 = 6.52616 troy ounces or $256.09 worth of silver. Excellent haul! 😎👍
 
UPDATE:

went back into the bank on 8/27 and got $32 more in nickels. There were like 4 or 5 rolls that were similar to the ones I had found above with the silver. However, this time there was no silver. Instead, in one of the rolls were 4 1950Ds that are in near BU condition (as are a lot of 1950Ds as people had saved them in the 1950s and 1960s).

The other denominations that this person brought in, even $40 in halves, were all a skunk. My gut is that the collector passed away and the heirs knew what coins are silver, so they kept those. They didn't know that certain nickels are silver. Just a guess.

nickels 8-27.webp
nickels 8-27a.webp
 
No other way to say it. Awesome dude. Just awesome!
 
On Friday (8/22) I went into a bank that is very close to where I live. They all know me in there and know I collect. They all the CWR nickels and dimes that they can (sometimes they hold some back because that is all they have). The only stipulation is that I don't dump any of the rolls back on them. So on Friday I had to do some other banking and the one teller had $20 in CWR nickels that she gave me. I looked at them at home and within those rolls I found 7 war nickels and a 1937 buffalo. One of the rolls was marked 1969D and that is what they all were.

So having found that, I went back and the second teller was also there. So then I got an additional $40 in nickels (I told them I found stuff - they often ask what I have found - and I even told them what to look for - but they have no interest in looking or collecting). 4 of those rolls ($8) were marked with certain years (1968, 1972, etc), so I knew those were duds, but the remaining $32 were loaded with war nickels.

I went back a third time thinking that there may be some other denominations that this person may have brought in. Well, out came more nickels, and I got another $28 (I was able to dump $28 of the ones I had before because that was all they had), and those were the same - lots of war nickels, a few buffaloes, and even 3 Liberty nickels that are well worn (although 1 was 1899, so it was good to get back into the 1800s club - albeit, barely). They said that the person brought in quarters, so I took $100 of those (I never search quarters), but there was nothing - actually many of the rolls were short, so I wound up with $94 - just chalk that up to the cost of doing business.

So all-in, having looked at $88 in nickels in total ($78 if you take out the rolls that were marked with a certain date, which were as advertised), the finds were:

116 war nickels:
1942P: 12
1942S: 9
1943P: 27
1943D: 1
1943S: 7
1944P: 12
1944D: 4
1944S: 7
1945P: 15
1945D: 7
1945S: 15

Buffaloes: 1936, 1937 (x2), 2 dateless
Liberty: 1899, 1902, 1903

Thanks for looking
View attachment 2222414View attachment 2222415View attachment 2222416
Nice, you scored! I think my war nickel record was somewhere around 22 from a box...the liberty nickels are pretty rare...you did amazing with those...finding buffalo nickels are always nice, especially if you can see the dates...big congratulations!
 
Big congrats on the nickels
 
Each war nickel contains 35% silver. The pure silver content in a single war nickel is approximately 0.05626 troy ounces. 116 nickles x 0.05626 = 6.52616 troy ounces or $256.09 worth of silver. Excellent haul! 😎👍
Just keeps climbing

Screenshot_20251012_093113_Chrome.webp
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom