Found a Milk Bottle

No gold in NY

Bronze Member
Mar 22, 2015
1,688
2,921
Detector(s) used
Whites Coin Master,
Whites Gold Master GMT, Whites MXSport
High banker/dredge,
DIY hand trommel,
DIY Miller table,
DIY fluidbed gold trap sluice,
Keene A-52 A-52s
2186 Wheaties
Primary Interest:
Other
I was at a huge antique and flea market at the local fairgrounds. When I spotted this , I remembered a similar one on this forum recently. Also it is from my home town where I graduated high school. Just had to have it. After a little talk got it for $3. A little scratched up, but so am I after 75 years. Tried to research Platt J. Smith and came up with nothing.


DSCN0731.JPG
 

Last edited:
Milk bottles are great finds if you ask me, especially if you find a local. Very nice!
 

Nice personally relevant score! It does appear to have a mid 1930s-early 40s look to it, does it have a date on the bottom? (on older milks it's a 2-digit number for the last 2 digits of the year, often in the very center and sometimes weak so hard to see).
 

You bought very well.Congrats.
 

No Gold I was one of the people that posted a Milk bottle similar to the one you found . Milk bottle collecting is a big hobby in the area where I live . When ever there is a public sale and the seller had a Milk bottle collection it is listed in the bill of sale .The scratches are part of their existence . The delivery driver would deliver milk door to door along his route. When the bottle was empty it was returned ,washed and reused as long as it did not get damaged .All of that was 50 plus years ago . Many of them ended up on a pile with all other garbage in a family dump and have spent the last 50 years there until some one like me finds it and thinks he has discovered a long lost treasure . Mostly the value is in finding something that is local to where you live
 

Plumbata, yes it does. In a circle it's 3E4. Could it be 1934?
 

Crusty, Thanks for the research. I'll print that out and place it in the bottle.
 

it use to be that milks were one of the kind of bottles you would levee at the dump . now that was 30 years ago. and when I started digging , milk still came in bottles. so go figure .
 

Nice score, and for what it's worth, I believe the National Bottle Museum is located in Ballston Spa.
 

sandchip, yes it is. haven't been there in years.
 

Ill tell ya many bottles cam be found at those places. Well done
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top