ID help

[dcinffxva]

I posted this on the ID forum, and was referred here. There seems to be some question on authenticity, which I have to admit I question also. This was found on a North Carolina beach on Monday.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A Handbook of Civil War Bullets and Cartridges - Grab it through Amazon!

[Bigcypresshunter]

Be patient. Someone will be along soon to help that is much more knowlegable than myself.
(I already gave my opinion)

 

[Trez]

UUUUGGGG!!!!

Have you found any real Spanish reales before?
If you have, congrats.....
If you haven't...KEEP LOOKING.

I should have wrote it more clear...

"Have you found any real Spanish reales before?"
KEEP LOOKING, because that ain't one.

Trez

 

[Moe (fl)]

Nice find!

What is its weight?

This would be a shield type cob. The 'S' on 2nd pic is the initial of the assayer.

HH.
Moe

 

[PyrateJim]

Actually, I believe the "S" would be the mint, in this case Seville, Spain. As ofr being authentic or not, I would have to say NOT, by the picture. The markings on the shield look more "cast" then stamped. Edges are too soft, rounded and have almost a "flattened" appearance.

Sorry, but I'd have to say "pass" on this one if it was offered at a show/shop.

 

[cuzcosquirrel]

It's a bad mold cast.