Is this a good trade?

[jamin_03]

I had an acquaintance that had a 1967 40%er and an 1976 commemorative Eisenhower in her deceased husband's collection. I gave her $5 for the two. what do you guys think... Was that an okay buy?

Jamin_03

 

[NjStacker22]

I'm going to assume the 76 Eisenhower is not silver? but I don't know much about commemorative coins. The 67 is worth about $4.80... right now.

 

[GlenDronach]

Yes, you're a little bit ahead of melt with the half + $1. Is the Eisenhower an S mint?

 

[BuffaloBoy]

i would have personally offered $10... even if the eisenhower commemorative from 1976 wasn't silver.

 

[jamin_03]

Nope. just D mint.