What's new

Kidd-Palmer Treasure Maps SOLVED by Oliver D. Smith

It was common practice for publishers in the US before 1989 not to change the year on the copyright page of a book in reprints unless there were major revisions or additions to the text (hence a revised/second edition). Prior to 1989, US law strictly required a formal copyright notice inside all published books. A reprint of an existing copyrighted text, with no or very small changes (such as spelling corrections or rearrangment of illustrations) creates no new intellectual property, so there is no legal obligation to copyright the book as a "derivative work" which requires substantial changes and permits a new copyright notice. As the writer of the Facebook post correctly pointed out: the second edition of The Mystery of Cabin Island was not published until 1966, so there was no reason for the copyright page to be updated in the 1934, 1959, 1960 and 1964 reprints—since the text of the book remained virtually the same as the first impression. The Facebook poster noted that sometimes to determine when books were reprinted, you have to look at dust jackets with artwork, adverts (typically at back of the book) as well as other bits of evidence as indicators of the print year.

In the UK (unlike the US), there was never a law that required a formal copyright notice to be published in books. This explains why Rainbow Island (1903, Ward, Lock & Co.) has no copyright year printed inside it. Most reprints of Rainbow Island do not either have the year they were printed (after the first impression), although a few do (I already showed these, including a 1910 reprint). This is why I previously explained to determine when the book was published and/or reprinted, you have to look at different lines of evidence:
  • Under British law (since the Copyright Act 1842), publishers up to 1973 were required to send copies of newly printed books (within one month) to the Department of Printed Books in the British Museum. The library stamped these incoming copies with the exact date they arrived to verify the legal-deposit provision of the Copyright Act 1842 and 1911. The Copyright Office of the British Museum also maintained an accession ledger by hand as a receipt. Today, publishers instead send copies directly to the British Library (under the British Library Act 1972 [which came into effect in July 1973], the British Library split from the British Museum to become an independent institution) and the accession ledger has been replaced with a computer database.
  • Literary magazines and newspapers, and trade journals (such as The Publishers’ Circular) published weekly lists of new book releases and reviews. Rainbow Island began appearing in review columns and publisher advertisements in late 1903.
  • The first impression of Rainbow Island had gilt lettering and decoration on its book cover (this did not appear in any reprint) and also the title page was printed in red and black writing (red writing does not appear in any reprint). This is why based on the book cover and title page, antiquarians and book specialists easily determined the first impression.
As mentioned here, I purchased a digital scan of the copy of Rainbow Island in the British Library and it is stamped:
"British Museum 3 OC 1903" (= 3 October 1903).
This is indisputably the date the British Museum recieved the copy of Rainbow Island and is the date on their accession ledger (the date the book was formally registered with the Department of Printed Books) so the book was recieved, catalogued and accessioned on 3 October 1903. The stamp inside the book also matches this period and is oval in shape. I am prevented for copyright reasons from posting it (as explained above), however, you can go to the British Library and see the book copy for yourself. I was in London a few weeks ago and visited the British Library. I have therefore seen and physically handled the book; the library staff clarified the aquisition/accession date as 3 October 1903 (the date of the stamp). The book copy held in the British Library is the first impression and contains the illustrations by Fred Pegram including the map of Rainbow Island. The map appears as a plate between pages 6 and 7. In some of the reprints, the map appears on different pages, for example, in the 1910 reprint I own (which has the print year on the title page), the map appears between pp. 16 and 17.
 
Last edited:
I am prevented for copyright reasons from posting it (as explained above)
Really? So far you have posted dozens of copyrighted book references to plead your case without fear of reprisal.

however, you can go to the British Library and see the book copy for yourself. I was in London a few weeks ago and visited the British Library. I have therefore seen and physically handled the book; the library staff clarified the aquisition/accession date as 3 October 1903 (the date of the stamp). The book copy held in the British Library is the first impression and contains the illustrations by Fred Pegram including the map of Rainbow Island.
You're saying that I would need to travel 11,000 miles (round trip) from my home to London to verify your observations?
Could you send me pics to my private email?
 
Really? So far you have posted dozens of copyrighted book references to plead your case without fear of reprisal.


You're saying that I would need to travel 11,000 miles (round trip) from my home to London to verify your observations?
Could you send me pics to my private email?
I posted a URL to the digital scan of the book (free access) you could download as a file from the British Library. The link expired two weeks ago but was available for a month. I paid £31.52 for the page scans. Regardless, I already proved the 1910 reprint (I own) contains the RI map (see scanned pages of the book from my printer below).

1793215858974.webp

1793216208931.webp

The reason I am legally prevented from posting digital scans of the 1903 first impression—is the British Library copyright their digital scans of books and they explicitly told me I do not have permission to post them publicly (I discussed this here) or I would be breaching their terms of service/contract (I agreed to for their digitisation services). However, there is/was nothing preventing me from sharing the URL to download the scans as a file (on their website), which is why I shared the URL so other forum members could download it. The British Library, for customers, makes digital scans of books downloadable as a file for a month (or four weeks). All that said, can you explain why the first impression matters to you? I have already proved the RI map appears in the 1910 reprint. The print date "1910" is written on the title page:

1793219361032.webp

If by some extremely improbable event (bordering on impossible, say 1 in 10¹⁰⁰) the map was absent from the first impression (1903) and what I saw/handled was fake, the library fabricated the acquisition/accession database entry of the book (3 October 1903) all as part of some elaborate conspiracy theory—the fact remains that seven years later the map appeared in the 1910 reprint. So why do these seven years even matter to you? :dontknow:
 
Last edited:
Randawg, I gotta agree, this horse done been flogged and ain't breathing. Mr. Smith has conclusively shown the map was published in the book Rainbow Island, all the way back to the original release in 1903. Time to stop beating the poor horse and move on.
 
I have already proved the RI map appears in the 1910 reprint. The print date "1910" is written on the title page:

Oh, but didn't you also "Prove" that the Rainbow Island map pic was included in the 1903 first edition? I was chastised on this thread for not agreeing with that "obvious fact". This makes your retraction (below) mildly gratifying.

the map was absent from the first impression (1903) and what I saw/handled was fake, the library fabricated the acquisition/accession database entry of the book (3 October 1903) all as part of some elaborate conspiracy theory—the fact remains that seven years later the map appeared in the 1910 reprint.

You verified that your 1903 book was confirmed to be "fake", and it was able to fool your supposed expert opinion. So why should anyone believe that the 1910 version is authentic? :dontknow:
 
Mr. Smith, best to stop responding to this nonsense. If Randawg wants to know the truth, he can look, and see for himself. Now that he knows where to look, it's a phenomenally easy task.
 
Oh, but didn't you also "Prove" that the Rainbow Island map pic was included in the 1903 first edition? I was chastised on this thread for not agreeing with that "obvious fact". This makes your retraction (below) mildly gratifying.



You verified that your 1903 book was confirmed to be "fake", and it was able to fool your supposed expert opinion. So why should anyone believe that the 1910 version is authentic? :dontknow:
I think this is the worst quote out of context I have seen on this forum. Yikes. What I actually said:
If by some extremely improbable event (bordering on impossible, say 1 in 10¹⁰⁰) the map was absent from the first impression (1903) and what I saw/handled was fake, the library fabricated the acquisition/accession database entry of the book (3 October 1903) all as part of some elaborate conspiracy theory—the fact remains that seven years later the map appeared in the 1910 reprint. So why do these seven years even matter to you?
You removed the bold text to misleadingly make it appear I stated the "1903 book was confirmed to be fake":
the map was absent from the first impression (1903) and what I saw/handled was fake, the library fabricated the acquisition/accession database entry of the book (3 October 1903) all as part of some elaborate conspiracy theory—the fact remains that seven years later the map appeared in the 1910 reprint.
My comment in its proper context was the opposite of how you distorted it. A probability of 1 in 10¹⁰⁰ (one in a googol) is almost indistinguishable from impossible. To put this in perspective, imagine a lottery jackpot with odds of approximately 1 in 45 million like UK National Lottery (Lotto) [1 in 45,057,474]. You would need to win the lottery jackpot 13 times consecutively, before the probability comes close to 1 in a googol (needless to say, no one has won the UK lottery jackpot 13 times in a row...) So I was obviously not stating or implying that the 1903 book I saw/handled was fake nor the library fabricated the acquisition/accession database entry of the book but describing an intentionally absurd hypothetical. My position has always been that the map is in the first book impression (1903). Anyway, the fact you are egregiously taking my words out of context does justify me now putting you on my ignore list and not further responding to you.🔚
 
Last edited:
Mr. Smith, best to stop responding to this nonsense. If Randawg wants to know the truth, he can look, and see for himself. Now that he knows where to look, it's a phenomenally easy task.
Correct, anyone can order for themselves a digital scan of the Rainbow Island map (1903 first impression) from the British Library or visit the library in person to verify the map is inside the book. I had to buy digital scans of pages 1 to 21 since I did not know what exact page the RI map is on, but I now know it is page 6 (the stamp with the date 3 October 1903 is page 5, which confirms the date the book was recieved, catalogued and accessioned). Although I do not have permission to post the digital scans for reasons I already explained, I can show a screenshot of the file and the JPGs (digital image files) I downloaded. The British Library charges £15.25 for a digital scan of a single book page and £0.58 pence for each subsequent page, so if Randawg72 wants the digital scans of pages 5 and 6 (the map and stamp), he can pay £15.83. It is as you say nonsense for him to continue denying the map is in the first impression. I agree I have wasted enough time on this.

1793421245639.webp
 
Last edited:
As I mentioned pages back, the map of Rainbow Island drawn by Fred Pegram does not appear in the American edition of Louis Tracy's novel, The Wings of the Morning. The American book publishers Edward J. Clode, Grosset & Dunlap and John C. Winston who published TWotM never included Pegram's map. It appeared in the British edition, under the title Rainbow Island, published by Ward, Lock & Co. I originally thought it only appeared in the British edition but I have now found an exception. I forgot to look at Canadian book publishers. The map interestingly appears in The Wings of the Morning: Rainbow Island by Toronto: McLeod & Allen. I managed to access a copy of this rare Canadian edition from The Library of the University of Toronto. There is no issue with copyright, so see the relevant pages below. The book's title is unusually both The Wings of the Morning and Rainbow Island (there are two title pages). The map appears on a plate between pages 68 and 69. This makes sense because Chapter IV "Rainbow Island" begins on page 68. In contrast, in the British edition (first impression and reprints) the map appears near the beginning of the book.

1793467420219.webp
1793467493762.webp

1793467570032.webp
1793467591236.webp

The Canadian edition contains no date of publication or print but we know the former: 1903. The print year can though reliably be dated pre-1917 because the book publisher Toronto: McLeod & Allen was founded in 1901 and dissolved in 1916; no books after that year were printed as "McLeod & Allen". The company was founded in 1901 by George J. McLeod (1870–1936) and Thomas Allen (1872–1951). In 1916, the book publisher and their business partnership was dissolved; both men then established businesses under their own names (for further information, see The Beginnings of the Book Trade in Canada, by George L. Parker). This is therefore proof the map in the Canadian edition appeared before 1917 and we know the publication year of the book (1903). So the range is 1903-1916. The first book title page narrows the print year by mentioning Tracy's other books: The Final War was published in 1896, An American Emperor was published in 1897, The Strange Disappearance of Lady Delia was published in 1901 but his subsequent popular book The Albert Gate Mystery (1904), is not listed. This strongly suggests the title page was printed during or immediately after 1903 and an archivist I spoke to from The Library of the University of Toronto, agreed with me. This book with the map is almost certainly the first impression (Canadian) and was printed c. 1903.

The book was reprinted by the same publisher (Toronto: McLeod & Allen) a few years later, sometime between 1907-1916, but without Pegram's illustrations and the RI map. Although the reprint does not either contain the publication or print year—1907 to 1916 as a window for the latter is determined based on advertisements in the book that establish a terminus post quem and the terminus ante quem is when the book publisher dissolved (concerning the former, the book contains an advertisement for Thomas W. Lawson's Friday the 13th which was published in 1907). I managed to find the book cover and pages of the Canadian reprint. The reprint is clearly cheaper; the illustrations and map were omitted to reduce manufacturing expenses. This might have occured c. 1914 with the outbreak of World War I which resulted in wartime material shortages of paper and labour shortages affected printing and manufacturing.

1793470364760.webp
1793470398137.webp
1793470433627.webp
 
Last edited:
I have now compiled a list of translations of Rainbow Island (aka Wings of the Morning) by Louis Tracy.

LanguageTranslated titleTranslatorPublisherYearNotes
DanishØens Hemmelighed (The Secret of the Island)Thor PetersenRoman-Magasinet, Copenhagen1908317 pages; Fred Pegram's illustrations
IcelandicÁ vængjum morgunroðans (On the Wings of the Dawn)Jón LevíWinnipeg: Columbia Press; Reykjavík: Vikuritið : Viðey; Sunnufell1915287 pages, reprinted in 1935 (376 pages), 1959 (222 pp.), 1976 and 1986 (211 pp.)
SwedishRegnbågsön (Rainbow Island)Oscar NachmanB. Wahlström, Stockholm1920158 pages; B. Wahlströms ungdomsböcker, no. 35; reprinted in 1933
FinnishSeikkailujen saari (Island of Adventures)Aito KareMinerva, Helsinki1923155 pages
NorwegianRegnbue-øya (Rainbow Island)C. PoulsenN. W. Damm & Søn1940De udødelige ungdomsbøkene, no. 17

You can read the Finnish translation here. Added to my collection are the Swedish translation (1920) and reprint (1933):

1794177601180.webp

Fred Pegram's illustrations (including Rainbow Island map) do not appear in the Swedish translation nor reprint, but they do appear in the Danish translation (1908). I spoke to an antiquarian who resides in Copenhagen who verified the map appears in the Danish translation: Øens Hemmelighed. Although he sold his copy about three years ago, he remembered the map being inside. The Danish translation is very rare and there are no current online sellers. Information about the Danish translation (from a bibliographic database) can be read here. Recently, I bought a copy of the Finnish translation (1923), as well as the Icelandic (1915). A list of the Icelandic reprints can be accessed here (catalogue of Icelandic libraries). The Icelandic translation title Á vængjum morgunroðans is interestingly On the Wings of the Dawn.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom