A picture would be great.
Not all meteorites are magnetic (though 99% are).
We have a meteorite (had to have it analyzed by a university to find out), because even an "expert" said it was not. It is not magnetic, - let me
rephrase that - there is one small spot that is weakly magnetic-about a 1/2-3/4 inch area), the rest is not.
Your best bet is to have a slice taken out - send it to the University of Arizona (Center of Meteorite Studies) - you pay shipping, they test for free - if it is a meteorite, they get to put it (the information and the little slice) into their database of known meteorites.
The biggest problem with meteorites is that, especially during the last 10 years - they are finding "unknown" meteorites - ones that aren't part of a known meteorite shower.
Beth