My TRX vs Garrett vs Vibra-Quatic2

[Digging Deeper]

Tonight I put my pinpointers to a head to head air test. I used a modern nickel as the target. I placed the nickel on a neutral surface and tested each pin pin pointer for the longest target indication.

Garrett Propointer 2"
Vibra-Quatic2 2"
Whites TRX (1) 4.5"
Whites TRX (2) 5"

I have no particular brand loyalty when it comes to pinpointers. There are things about all of these I like and dislike. I have listed them below.

Whites TRX: $160
Pros: adjustable sensitivity, very powerful, can use both AA and 9volt batteries.
It also has a dead section just above the tip which really helps locating small objects in the side wall of the hole.
Cons: ground balance is lost on occasion and is fixed by pressing the power button once. Not waterproof.

Garrett Propointer: $120
Pros: tough, has digging edge and a great light. It will not come on in the holster which is good. I have used this one for several years.
Cons: does not have great depth in comparison to the TRX. It false beeps sometimes when the tip touches the ground and gets any pressure applied to it while swiping though the dirt in the hole. (I had this repaired and have had no trouble with this since) I is not waterproof but I understand it's new replacement is. I will try the new one out as soon as I can find one.

Vibra-Aquatic2: $150
Pros: great for diving, lights and vibrated,
Cons: I don't like the way you have got to invert it to turn it on and off (no switch). Big and heavy, very short range , requires motion to signal a target.

I use the TRX the most now and the Propointer as a second back up (got another TRX as a first back up) . I very seldom use the Vibra-Quatic 2 unless I'm diving or in a deep creek. It was a gift and it serves it's purpose pretty well.
Hope this was helpful and HH.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Cry Of The Eagle: History And Legends Of The Cherokee Indians And Their Buried Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[DiggerinVA]

New Garrett Pro pointer AT....will be waterproof...has 3 sense settings and orange with a security loop!!! cant wait!!

 

[Digging Deeper]

I'm gonna get one as soon as I can find one.

 

[dirtscratcher]

I'm gonna get one as soon as I can find one.

I swore off garret after two bad propointers but will probably buy one of the new ones just to cure the itch. So far the trx to me is the best out of the old Garrett and minelab.

 

[markkeele]

I have had three different propointers, and all have been awful, and the customer service was not at all good, I had the first one three months and the switch went bad, the other two have had falsing issues, I have had to pay shipping to send them back and its been less than a year since the original purchase, I was told by customer service the last time I spoke to them about the problem that maybe I was being to picky, will never buy another Garrett product,

 

[PostalTwo]

the trx is waterproof

 

[dirtscratcher]

I have had three different propointers, and all have been awful, and the customer service was not at all good, I had the first one three months and the switch went bad, the other two have had falsing issues, I have had to pay shipping to send them back and its been less than a year since the original purchase, I was told by customer service the last time I spoke to them about the problem that maybe I was being to picky, will never buy another Garrett product,

The funny thing is there are people with the same experience and they still swear the Garrett is the best there is. I have bought the new one after swearing off garretts and it seems to work good but not as deep as the whites and Ive grown to like the whites the best for sensing only at the tip.

 

[johnnycat]

I sold my Garrett and bought the White's just to try the new kid on the block. So far I don't regret it. Longevity is the name of the game...We shall see.

 

[Detector Wars]

The funny thing is there are people with the same experience and they still swear the Garrett is the best there is. I have bought the new one after swearing off garretts and it seems to work good but not as deep as the whites and Ive grown to like the whites the best for sensing only at the tip.

There's your answer.

 

[Detector Wars]

Cons: I don't like the way you have got to invert it to turn it on and off (no switch). Big and heavy, very short range , requires motion to signal a target.

That would be very unpractical, these things really need a switch. It's also too big to conceal.

 

[Jackalope]

For comparison purposes: On a nickel, at greatest sensitivity, I have the following:

Makro Pointer: 2"

ML Pro-Find: 2"

Vibra-Probe 570: 1.5"