Then take the (old government trail) to San Carlos. Where the trail turns south , you will see over the point of the ridge a rock standing in the brush ,it looks like a man. This is where I always leave the trail.
Where is the the old government trail that turns south. How hard is it to follow the trail to San Carlos? It will lead someone to the area. As told by Holmes. It sounds easy.
A big clue as to where “a portion” of the trail passes by, is right there in the Holmes manuscript. In the very same monologue of directions, just preceding says from 2nd water, we are to get onto the trail to San Carlos, then after the trail turns to the south, is where you can see the next leg of the treasure trail. The Rock Man. Waltz says when the trail turns to the south, the next leg goes to the left …. (Eastbound).
From the trail we are to see something over the point of a ridge.
Hear is a question for you all. From 2nd water (today’s 2nd water) we continue to the trail. Besides the 2nd water trail, what other trail is anywhere in the vicinity?
Yes, Boulder Canyon is just east of 2nd water, and heads in right direction… southward..
So what about the part of turning to the south?
If Boulder Canyon contains the trail, then there must be a place where it stops weaving back and forth, and straightens out in a south direction.
There is an area that matches up to the description. It is just north of where needle canyon comes into Boulder canyon. The trail is slightly elevated off the canyon floor in that section, and it is easy to see above all the brush in the bottom of the canyon. Looking southward up Boulder canyon, there are canyon walls on the west, and on the east.
“Over the point of a ridge” we are supposed to be able to see the next landmark.
Here is a photo of me standing at the crossroads of 2nd water trail, and Boulder canyon trail.
After Boulder canyon straightens out …. Yes in a southerly direction … here is what can be seen over the point of the ridge, the east ridge.

A large rock formation is sticking up so that the upper portion of it is visible from the trail down in Boulder canyon. I am looking up to the east ridge, right up that draw, is where it looks like the treasure trail leads …. If 2nd water is same 2nd water.
On this rock man, only his head and left shoulder are visible above the ridge. The saguaros sticking up below him, are part of “the brush” that it looks like the rock man is standing in. (Or behind)
Sincerely, Idahodutch