What's new

Old government trail to San Carlos.

nobodie

Hero Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2015
Messages
615
Reaction score
911
Golden Thread
0
Location
Phx. A.Z.
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Then take the (old government trail) to San Carlos. Where the trail turns south , you will see over the point of the ridge a rock standing in the brush ,it looks like a man. This is where I always leave the trail.
Where is the the old government trail that turns south. How hard is it to follow the trail to San Carlos? It will lead someone to the area. As told by Holmes. It sounds easy.
 
Then take the (old government trail) to San Carlos. Where the trail turns south , you will see over the point of the ridge a rock standing in the brush ,it looks like a man. This is where I always leave the trail.
Where is the the old government trail that turns south. How hard is it to follow the trail to San Carlos? It will lead someone to the area. As told by Holmes. It sounds easy.
A big clue as to where “a portion” of the trail passes by, is right there in the Holmes manuscript. In the very same monologue of directions, just preceding says from 2nd water, we are to get onto the trail to San Carlos, then after the trail turns to the south, is where you can see the next leg of the treasure trail. The Rock Man. Waltz says when the trail turns to the south, the next leg goes to the left …. (Eastbound).

From the trail we are to see something over the point of a ridge.

Hear is a question for you all. From 2nd water (today’s 2nd water) we continue to the trail. Besides the 2nd water trail, what other trail is anywhere in the vicinity?

Yes, Boulder Canyon is just east of 2nd water, and heads in right direction… southward..

So what about the part of turning to the south?
If Boulder Canyon contains the trail, then there must be a place where it stops weaving back and forth, and straightens out in a south direction.

There is an area that matches up to the description. It is just north of where needle canyon comes into Boulder canyon. The trail is slightly elevated off the canyon floor in that section, and it is easy to see above all the brush in the bottom of the canyon. Looking southward up Boulder canyon, there are canyon walls on the west, and on the east.

“Over the point of a ridge” we are supposed to be able to see the next landmark.

Here is a photo of me standing at the crossroads of 2nd water trail, and Boulder canyon trail.

IMG_0251.webp

After Boulder canyon straightens out …. Yes in a southerly direction … here is what can be seen over the point of the ridge, the east ridge.

IMG_0016.webp
A large rock formation is sticking up so that the upper portion of it is visible from the trail down in Boulder canyon. I am looking up to the east ridge, right up that draw, is where it looks like the treasure trail leads …. If 2nd water is same 2nd water.

On this rock man, only his head and left shoulder are visible above the ridge. The saguaros sticking up below him, are part of “the brush” that it looks like the rock man is standing in. (Or behind)

Sincerely, Idahodutch
 
Then take the (old government trail) to San Carlos. Where the trail turns south , you will see over the point of the ridge a rock standing in the brush ,it looks like a man. This is where I always leave the trail.
Where is the the old government trail that turns south. How hard is it to follow the trail to San Carlos? It will lead someone to the area. As told by Holmes. It sounds easy.
Good catch Nobodie! To understand that part of the route is the most important in regards to clean the image and to see the real one.
If you pay attention, Waltz separated himself from what Holmes would has to do. Waltz said " this is where I ( he not Holmes ) always leave the trail ". Waltz was leaving the trail in regards to go to the mine which is below from the low peak that is located in the saddle above, as following up the long ridge. Who was going to the left of the trail? Waltz not Holmes.
That Waltz's incorrect expression changed all the image of the route. That mistake was done maybe because in the beginning Waltz wanted to send Holmes to follow his route, but understanding would be more difficult for Holmes to find the location from below, Waltz changed suddenly the direction in his naration, causing a collision of words which were misunderstood by Holmes. So think about, why Waltz would send someone to follow up a long ridge if there would not be existing a possibility to do so?
 
Last edited:
If the (trail) that goes to San Carlos turns (south). Is it possible that everything that Holmes said is maybe North of San Carlos? It could be why Jacob went to Florence from time to time. Like when he went to Florence and the people there supposedly asked where was his partner (if he had a partner). Jacob went to Florence a few times. It's just a thought since no one has been given credit for finding the mine. Maybe everybody is looking in the wrong areas.
 
Last edited:
Hi nobodie,
The trail to San Carlos went through the Superstition Mountains, and was not a straight line through. I was only concerned with parts of the trail that might go near today’s 2nd water.

The directions do not say to go to San Carlos, but to get onto the trail for a little while. (Just until the landmark is spotted after the trail turns to the south). After seeing the rock man, we are to leave the trail. Waltz went left of the trail.

The trail continued on, but to get to his mine, he would leave the trail after seeing the rock man.

When traveling south and you take a left, you would then be headed east.

I am not sure where the Trail to San Carlos turned eastwards, but it was south of today’s Boulder Canyon. It might have been Bull Pass that was part of the trail to S.Carlos, or maybe it continued south up East Boulder for a bit, and then east just south of Blacktop Mesa 🤷🏼‍♂️

Either way, Waltz has us going left of the trail while we are traveling south along the trail …. After getting on it from 2nd Water.

There used to be some old maps that showed military trails, I think here on T-Net. What looked to be Bull pass was on it. Then from west side of Bull pass it looked like it branched different directions. One went northwards down Boulder canyon. Another went opposite direction up East Boulder southward, and a third went NW and I think is where the Black Mesa Trail today.

Idahodutch
 
If the (trail) that goes to San Carlos turns (south). Is it possible that everything that Holmes said is maybe North of San Carlos? It could be why Jacob went to Florence from time to time. Like when he went to Florence and the people there supposedly asked where was his partner (if he had a partner). Jacob went to Florence a few times. It's just a thought since no one has been given credit for finding the mine. Maybe everybody is looking in the wrong areas.
Nobodie
Don't be so concerned about where the Military trail is in it's existence, as there never was a specific Military trail going through the Supes. Waltz and others I'm sure, spotted the Military occasionally walking through the Supes at different times in different canyons - so it's not a specific path you're looking for. It's just a general comment that the military did in fact come through.
-SpartanOC
 
If the (trail) that goes to San Carlos turns (south). Is it possible that everything that Holmes said is maybe North of San Carlos? It could be why Jacob went to Florence from time to time. Like when he went to Florence and the people there supposedly asked where was his partner (if he had a partner). Jacob went to Florence a few times. It's just a thought since no one has been given credit for finding the mine. Maybe everybody is looking in the wrong areas.
Waltz was giving instructions from the north to the south. Usually, the Military/Gov trails were following already worned Indian trails, which were used by Natives for game or camps in those mountains. Waltz told Holmes to follow Government trail and to Julia to follow the Indian trail, which we can conclude they were the same.
The dilema is, in the Superstitions, the Gov/Military/Indian trails to San Carlos ( another name who promts to natives as a reservation ) have multiple turns to the south, so someone has to find out the right location which is mentioned in the clues. Trail to the south, canyon to the left ( not east ).
 
Waltz was giving instructions from the north to the south. Usually, the Military/Gov trails were following already worned Indian trails, which were used by Natives for game or camps in those mountains. Waltz told Holmes to follow Government trail and to Julia to follow the Indian trail, which we can conclude they were the same.
The dilema is, in the Superstitions, the Gov/Military/Indian trails to San Carlos ( another name who promts to natives as a reservation ) have multiple turns to the south, so someone has to find out the right location which is mentioned in the clues. Trail to the south, canyon to the left ( not east ).
IMG_0551.webp

All,
Attached is a GE snip showing the section of trail between 2nd water junction, and the spot to turn left of the trail. (Imo)

Markmar,
Your response maybe did not take into consideration the actual section of path that waltz was directing us towards, if 2nd water is the ticket.

It should be noted that today’s 2nd water, is not conclusive, it just has some very interesting outcomes if it is.

From 2nd water entry point, (the bottom end of the yellow line that is marked on the image), to the area where we are to go left of the trail, is shy of 3 miles by a little bit.
We can see lots of wiggling in the trail as we head southwards up the canyons, following the trail.

I really see one large jog to the south, and that jog is marked with the lower of the 2 red arrows.

Then there is another jog that waltz may or may not have been referring to, and it a smaller jog but it obstructs the view until you get around it. It is marked with the upper red arrow.

Let’s be direct here, in this application….. in my mind, there is no “delima” because there is at most (2) turns to the south in that stretch of the trail, is there markmar?

Bad form markmar (imo)

Nice try though, you almost made it sound like a applicable argument to rebut my earlier post.

And your comment about my using the word “east” instead of the word left. 🤪

That was just you, being you, trying to stir up something over nothing.

In that application, East and Left are same direction. I tire of your silly arguments.
It sounds like I’m not alone in that.

Anyway, have a good one 🤓👍

Idahodutch
 
Last edited:
Nobodie,
In the last post, the GE snip shows the path between 2nd water and turning left, is about 15,000 feet, or just shy of 3 miles. The hard parts of that section is all the stream bed crossings. The wear a person out. 🥵
Otherwise, it is an easy hike.

Idahodutch
 
Waltz was giving instructions from the north to the south………….
The dilema is, in the Superstitions, the Gov/Military/Indian trails to San Carlos ( another name who promts to natives as a reservation ) have multiple turns to the south, so someone has to find out the right location which is mentioned in the clues. Trail to the south, canyon to the left ( not east ).

Markmar,
I almost did not catch your alteration above, of the same clue that you are trying to blame me with.

As explained earlier, in the application used, that being, if 2nd water is same 2nd water from the clue, then for that one spot, yeah they are the same direction. However to be fair, in my posts, several times I used the word left, but once I used the word East. That’s where it looks like you were trying to stir something up over a “nothing burger” 🤔

The clue does say to go left of the trail. 👍

Nowhere in that clue does it say “canyon to the left”. That is what I consider “actual alteration” of a clue.

So desperate to show me wrong, you’re grabbing things out of context here, but in so doing, you revealed the very offense in yourself, that you are trying to blame me of.

I probably wasted my words.

Idahodutch
 
Markmar,
I almost did not catch your alteration above, of the same clue that you are trying to blame me with.

As explained earlier, in the application used, that being, if 2nd water is same 2nd water from the clue, then for that one spot, yeah they are the same direction. However to be fair, in my posts, several times I used the word left, but once I used the word East. That’s where it looks like you were trying to stir something up over a “nothing burger” 🤔

The clue does say to go left of the trail. 👍

Nowhere in that clue does it say “canyon to the left”. That is what I consider “actual alteration” of a clue.

So desperate to show me wrong, you’re grabbing things out of context here, but in so doing, you revealed the very offense in yourself, that you are trying to blame me of.

I probably wasted my words.

Idahodutch
It has nothing to do with your posts and your theory. It's my version on how that clue would be better to use. If there would be a long ridge close by, for sure there would be and a canyon beside, at least on one side of that ridge. I know for sure how going to the left of the trail when it turns south, you will continue in a canyon which runs almost parallel with that long ridge. There is no another place to go. For this Waltz said to Holmes how it's too steep to go down to his camp from the top of the low peak, and he ( Holmes ) should go to the mouth of the canyon ( when the trail turns south ) and back ( below the steep side of the low peak ), in regards to find the hidden camp.
Also my posts were adressed to Nobodie, the person who asked for answers.
 
Idahodutch
In the Waltz era were not named yet the locations on what todays are the First Water and Second Water in the Superstitions. These clues, work the same as the clue of the Gov/Indian trail. told by Waltz to two different persons ( explained above ). So the clues on the waters are working like this: Waltz told Holmes to go to first water and after to the second water, and Waltz told Julia to go to Verde River and after to cross the Salt River at the Rocky Shallows ( Mormon Flat ).
So, first water = Verde River and second water = Salt River. We have discussed these clues in this forum few years ago, but or you didn't read it or not pay the proper attention.
 
Idahodutch, You wrote:
" So desperate to show me wrong, you’re grabbing things out of context here, but in so doing, you revealed the very offense in yourself, that you are trying to blame me of."

In my world this looks like a form of persecution mania. Ok, just to end this I write: I belive how you are the only one who found the LDM location, but I'm free to express my own opinions parallel with what others opinions would be. Two different opinions doesn't mean a direct threat or an offense of any kind to anyone of the two writers. So , don't compare everything I wrote with what you are writing, because our opinions are for two different images from two different locations.
 
Idahodutch
In the Waltz era were not named yet the locations on what todays are the First Water and Second Water in the Superstitions. These clues, work the same as the clue of the Gov/Indian trail. told by Waltz to two different persons ( explained above ). So the clues on the waters are working like this: Waltz told Holmes to go to first water and after to the second water, and Waltz told Julia to go to Verde River and after to cross the Salt River at the Rocky Shallows ( Mormon Flat ).
So, first water = Verde River and second water = Salt River. We have discussed these clues in this forum few years ago, but or you didn't read it or not pay the proper attention.
Markmar,
I would not be so sure if I was you, about any of what you just wrote.

If I remember correctly, you were not received as well as you think, concerning your summations, but continue to believe what ever. 😎
 
Idahodutch, You wrote:
" So desperate to show me wrong, you’re grabbing things out of context here, but in so doing, you revealed the very offense in yourself, that you are trying to blame me of."

In my world this looks like a form of persecution mania. Ok, just to end this I write: I belive how you are the only one who found the LDM location, but I'm free to express my own opinions parallel with what others opinions would be. Two different opinions doesn't mean a direct threat or an offense of any kind to anyone of the two writers. So , don't compare everything I wrote with what you are writing, because our opinions are for two different images from two different locations.
This is just another example of you projecting your behaviors into others. The pattern is very recognizable, markmar. It doesn’t require your awareness to be true.

In my book, it is a definite form of deception, first the initial offence, then more if you get called out for it. Often times you go on the attack, or attempt to turn it around onto the one calling you out. Maybe you don’t realize how predictable it has become. 🤷🏼‍♂️
 
This is just another example of you projecting your behaviors into others. The pattern is very recognizable, markmar. It doesn’t require your awareness to be true.

In my book, it is a definite form of deception, first the initial offence, then more if you get called out for it. Often times you go on the attack, or attempt to turn it around onto the one calling you out. Maybe you don’t realize how predictable it has become. 🤷🏼‍♂️
You have to cool down. Nobody wants to attack you here. Is only your illusions and you. You are right in everything you write, as everyone in this forum. Results make the difference.
 
You have to cool down. Nobody wants to attack you here. Is only your illusions and you. You are right in everything you write, as everyone in this forum. Results make the difference.
🤣 there you go projecting again.
Practice makes perfect I guess ….. or almost. 😎 all but the little jab at the end.

I think you just can’t help yourself. 🥹
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom