Sounds like a good game...I'll play
2014 Top Ten Wish List. This may seem lofty, but I've crossed off a lot of stuff. Was always reluctant to put gold coin on the list, but it's on this time.
#1 Cache
#2 Complete Shoe Buckle
#3 Silver Thimble
#4 Silver Buckle
#5 Good Military Button (with a bit of value)
#6 Any Dollar Sized Silver, 8R, Dutch Dollar, English Crown etc.
#7 Victorian 50 cent piece
#8 Plate of any kind
#9 Gold (solid) Pocket Watch (a solid silver would do...for awhile)
#10 Gold Coin
Alternates,
Colonial US Copper
Good luck, some have made their way under my coil and others I still feel like I'm a million miles away.... and I guess you always are until you dig it.
The cache, I have never found anything close... but when you hunt plowed fields that makes sense. I figure we have likely found many caches over the years, just didn't know it because the plow got there first. It sure would be interesting to know though!
God the stuff I have dug and never a large intact Colonial shoe buckle! But again, another one where the plow isn't kind.
Silver thimble... that's a funny one. First took about 5 years, and 2 and 3 in the two weeks following,
Silver buckle. Can't really think what form such a thing would come in, but if we dug one, I'm sure it would be something nice.
Good military button with value.... check!

check check check check check
I'm also good for the dollar sized coin. 1777 8 reale and 1812 3 Shilling.
Victoria 50 cents. Jeeze... I have been lucky just to get there with quarters! Only two of those so far so have a hard time believing a half will happen. You'll need a whole lot more luck than I on that one.
Plate I've found an 1812 era plain cross belt plate and a Rev war GR cartridge plate, so check on that one.
Pocket watch.. never cared because you'd never find a working one. If there's was lots of gold cool, silver I don't care.
Gold coin. Can never see it happening.
American Colonial... have found several.
So we'll see how long it takes you to gain on me, or if I can ever get close to crossing those other things off. I can see myself finding more of the same, maybe even a few times over before I find the stuff I've never dug. I do believe I will find that shoe buckle though!