What's new

Update on diamond stud earring found tuesday

scaupus

Hero Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2011
Messages
900
Reaction score
540
Golden Thread
0
Location
Not too far from a beach
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
I found a diamond stud earring yesterday, but figured it was fake. It's about 3/4 carat in size.

I picked up a UV light today and the stone fluoresces a deep blue, which indicates a diamond, although not a good one, as the lower the quality, the bluer the stone will fluoresce. In addition, it passes all the tests I could do on it without removing it from the mount:

the girdle is frosty, condensed breath evaporates from it almost instantly, I cannot read through it, using a loupe it appears to contain inclusions, and the facets are sharp not rolled, and it scratches glass (not supposed to do that as it can damage the stone). Also the facets are shades of gray, not colored, and you cannot see the bottom through the top table.

So, I think it's a diamond. Here are the tests you can do at home:

[size=10pt][size=10pt]"The transparency test. Flip your diamond upside down and place it over some newsprint. If you can clearly read through the stone, it's not a diamond. (Beware, some low cut diamonds or stones such as emeralds can be read through.)
The fog test. Put your diamond in front of your mouth and fog it like you would fog a mirror. If it stays fogged for 2-4 seconds, it's a fake. A real diamond will disperse the heat instantaneously so by the time you look at it, it has already cleared up. Oil and dirt on the stone can affect reliability and the test is not accurate at all on doublets where the top of the stone is diamond and the bottom is cubic zirconia glued together.
Test for weight. The most popular diamond simulant (fake) is a cubic zirconia. C.Z.'s will weigh approximately 55% more than diamonds for the same shape and size. Use a carat or gram scale to see if the impostor tips the scales too much.
The U.V. test. Many diamonds will show fluorescence of blue if put under an ultra violet light or black light. 99% of all fakes don't do this; so, a positive identification of medium to strong blue would indicate a diamond. Diamonds with blue fluorescence can be as much as 20% less valuable; however, lack of blue fluorescence doesn't mean it's a fake; it could be a better quality diamond.
The under the loop test. With a magnifying lens, there are some things you can look for on the stone that might give away its identity:

Look at your diamond from the top and see how the facets (the cuts on top of the diamond) are joined. They should be sharp but not rolled.
Is the girdle faceted or frosty (yes, then it's a diamond) or waxy and slick (yes, then it's a fake.)
Under magnification, look into your diamond for flaws (carbon, pinpoints, small cracks.) It's very hard to put inclusions into a fake.
Look at the stamps inside the setting. A stamp of "10K, 14K, 18K, 585, 750, 900, 950, PT, Plat" indicates the setting is real gold or platinum. This gives a better chance that the stone in it is real as well. Look for any "C.Z." stamps. This will tell you the center stone is not a diamond. "
[/size][/size]
 
Upvote 0
It does not strike me as being a diamond, and I am a jeweler. It is also smaller than 3/4 of a carat. I think instead of speculating, you ought to take it to a jeweler and let them test it.
 
Hope it is real, but just about everything scratches glass: quartz, garnet, topaz, sapphire, tanzanite, opal, andesine, zircon, and on and on and on. Zirconia also, but we don't speak of that.

A jeweler should have one of a half dozen diamond testers, and if anyone charges you, then they shouldn't expect your business in the future, as well as a bunch of bad mouthing. Find one that isn't busy. I would test it for you, but I am not a diamond guy. Don't like them.
 
Gemee,

First, allow me to say I think it's very cool a professional jeweler would make an observation on the stone in this forum, I thank you very much. May I ask, what factors led you to feel it is not a diamond? The unmarked mount which appeared to me to be sterling is what makes me the most skeptical.

Regarding the carat weight - the stone measures just over 4mm across, using calipers. I read that one carat stones are from 5.5 to 7 mm, so I figured it is likely to be somewhat under 3/4 carat, but probably more than half a carat; 3/4 was just an approximation for publication.

I did show this to a jeweler (well, a jewelry vendor, not a high end shop), and her machine gave several negative readings on stones she knew were diamonds including the ring on her finger. She said the negative readings were probably due to the stones being dirty. I read that the stone should be clean when tested. My stone definitely was dirtier than hers. So, that was not too useful.

I took it to another jeweler in a more expensive shop, but she said she only does appraisals, not quicky opinions. I can understand she doesn't want to compromise her professionalism, I didn't have an issue with that.

Would you happen to know a good jeweler in South Florida with a soft spot for detectorists who will check it properly for free?

How reliable is the UV test if the stone turns a deep deep blue under UV light? I read online that 99% of fakes do not fluoresce blue. In your experience is that true? I like this test since the stone doesn't have to be cleaned nor removed from the mount. Also, when the stone turns very, very blue, as this one did, it doesn't seem to require any experience to make the call.

How about the frosty girdle? How common are fakes with frosty girdles?

Thanks, Larry
 
It's fake!

ok, i got the answer on this. The girdle is actually shiny not frosty. And the stone does not fluoresce, it was merely reflecting purple light. Condensation does seem to disappear very fast, but I'm guessing now that it's slower than a real diamond.

I'm satisfied it's not a diamond. Also, it just never seemed bright enough to be a real diamond.

Sorry if I got anyone's hopes up. :'(

Today I read by far the most informative piece on diamonds so far, and it really helped me understand what I was looking at tonight:
.
http://www.answers.com/topic/diamond-simulant

I am very interested now in observing more stones, both real and fake. This is a lot of fun, and a good skill to develop.

Anyway, this stud is pretty nice as a fake, relatively speaking. I don't know if it's good enough for me get my ear pierced, though. 8)

Before I sell it on Etsy for $6, I might get a real jeweler to look at it to confirm, just to be prudent. But I'm quite sure I got it right this time.
 
Just a suggestion - you might be able to take that stone to JCPenny's and even the Jewerly store in Sears- when I worked retail both places would test stones for free - this was years ago- so things might have changed, but they used to do it for free! I even hit the mall when I found some shineys and some of the higher class places would check things for free like Zales. so it's worth asking- just say I found this- can you tell me if it's real or not- not what it costs - they usually don't give appraisals- just a yes or no...

just my 2 cents. if you do manage to find some place that works out -post about it please...

Thanks.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom