I agree that one has to expect some amount of a premium to added to the spot price of smaller purchases. If a person wants silver to stockpile over, and well above, what seems to be needed for the rough days ahead, they'll get it most any way they can.
If a person lives in rent house or apartment, they usually own less of other material items, so they want silver to have and use for their future basic needs. They'll need a lot of it. If a person lives in a home that is almost paid for, or completely paid for, they have to weigh paying that premium to get silver or spending the paper dollars for long term needs like food storage, ample water reserves, and items of need or high cost that might not be there to buy after the collapse dust settles.
Most people in 2014 pay a higher premium because they are either scare of the future or greedy and betting on the price doubling, tripling, or even more. Sterling silver is getting harder and harder to find at garage sales, but as of last weekend I can say it can still be found.... Three years ago I could buy a lot more and spend a lot less.... I guess I paid somewhat of a "Premium" when I ended up offering/paying $51.00 for Sterling Jewelry that weighed a total of 176 grams and a scrap worth of $110.00. But, having it in hand, and equaling 5.23 ounces of pure sliver, it's still silver, it can be sold for either jewelry or PM scrap .... and it's half the price of Spot this first week of March....
What makes me sad and feel for those selling silver at garage sales, is that even though they live in Middle Income to Higher Income homes and neighborhoods, they have little or no awareness, much less a plan, of what to do about the coming economic reset...

After starting at the 52 minute mark and listening to Lindsay Williams' most recent public information, I think you'll know if you are going to willingly pay a premium over Spot Silver....
Lindsey Williams & Dr. Rodrigo Rodriguez - K-Talk - Mills Crenshaw -February 19th 2014 - YouTube