The material in the second Brewerton looks like a high grade, local flint. There are a number of flints and cherts that occur in Pennsylvania, including many local black and grey flints and cherts that vary enormously in quality. Some are dull in finish, some are full of rind and inner defects, some are of nicer quality but of matt finish, some are shiny but of indifferent to poor quality, and some are of excellent quality and finish - like your piece. All are local flints, and the same exposure can produce many different grades.
I have collected fields in Pennsylvania where I know where the nearest local exposures of flint are located. The texture, color and quality of the flint on these fields are all over the place, as described above.
artorius