Back on the board- US PEWTER! CW/Colonial Relics

Patriot Relics

Silver Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2014
Messages
3,709
Reaction score
5,618
Golden Thread
5
Location
Lowcountry, South Carolina / Richmond, Virginia
🥇 Banner finds
5
Detector(s) used
CTX-3030, Deus XP II
Primary Interest:
Relic Hunting
Hey guys,

Out out this past week a few times despite the 100 degree weather and continuous thunderstorms. Hung up the DEUS and hit the coast with the mighty CTX. While I've come to love the XP as my inland machine, the CTX is the superior machine on the highly mineralized salt flats. The first site is a tried and true artillery site, over the past year producing a few War of 1812/CW relics. Not a ton of targets, but did manage 3 dropped bullets...2 rings but not 100% confident on the caliber...perhaps from a revolver, along with a few round balls.

20160718_182501.webp20160718_182555.webp

The next site was a colonial trash pit that always seems to produce a military button...the result of surplus military uniforms utilized to outfit slave labor in the 1850s. While I've hit the site dozens of times, fresh erosion revealed a new clay layer full of pottery and iron. By sweeping slowly and picking away between the iron I was rewarded with my first US cuff (1808-1830 30av in Alberts) and a pewter trouser button. The condition of this pewter cuff is incredible compared to the inland ones I've dug in the past.

20160718_183047.webp20160718_183100.webp20160718_175822.webp20160718_175836.webp

Among the iron trash I did manage a handful of civilian buttons and an interesting 1 piece ball button.

20160718_182942.webp20160718_183020.webp20160718_183022.webp

My favorite civilian digs were a copper ring and a glass jeweled buckle fragment. Any info on the ring is greatly appreciated-

20160718_182731.webp20160718_182736.webp20160718_182800.webp20160718_182808.webp

Also dug a rat tail pewter spoon fragment and an unknown copper alloy...thing:dontknow:

20160718_183132.webp20160718_183137.webp20160718_183114.webp20160718_183117.webp

All in all a productive week in the mud, handful of brass ship building nails, harmonica, and assorted surface finds to round it out. Enjoy the pictures and good luck out there!

20160718_182347.webp20160718_182410.webp20160718_190314.webp
 

Last edited:
Upvote 20
That's an awesome US cuff button man :thumbsup: It's weird how some pewters are in better shape than others. I wonder if a different alloy made them hold up better. I've dug toasted ones and perfect ones from the same soil. Great hunt!

In my experience pewter recovered in tidal mud seems to survive far better than inland...perhaps a combination of moisture and limited oxidation
 

You won't find a better pewter US. I have found the pewter 4 holers in 1830s camps in Oklahoma and 1850s camps in Texas. I understand they were underwear buttons.
 

That's a great bunch of finds...I don't recall seeing that particular button before.
 

Nice looking US button, great recoveries!
 

You won't find a better pewter US. I have found the pewter 4 holers in 1830s camps in Oklahoma and 1850s camps in Texas. I understand they were underwear buttons.

I've dug a few of the 4 hole pewters, underwear button is correct
 

Great stuff as usual. I'm curious about the little ball button. How old d you think it is? I dug a few in England and always wondered.
 

Great stuff as usual. I'm curious about the little ball button. How old d you think it is? I dug a few in England and always wondered.

The closest examples I've found online appear to originate across the pond and are labeled as 17th century
 

The closest examples I've found online appear to originate across the pond and are labeled as 17th century

Cool thanks for the info. I guess that means you are on a very old spot, keep digging holes and I hope you find more great things.

I can't wait to get my buttons back. I've got some good ones, and I'll probably ask you colonial guys about a few of them when I do.
 

Cool thanks for the info. I guess that means you are on a very old spot, keep digging holes and I hope you find more great things.

I can't wait to get my buttons back. I've got some good ones, and I'll probably ask you colonial guys about a few of them when I do.

Looking forward to an England dig in April, hopefully you get your buttons back soon
 

In my experience pewter recovered in tidal mud seems to survive far better than inland...perhaps a combination of moisture and limited oxidation

A bunch of nice finds there Jon! Contrary to your experience, I haven't had much luck with pewters coming from a salt water beach as they're generally in poor shape although an occasional nice one appears now and then. I'm leaning toward what Brad said, and maybe the composition of the pewter is the key factor. Pewter was generally comprised of more than 90% tin with much smaller amounts of copper and antimony added as hardening agents, and sometimes a little lead which darkens the appearance. I'm sure the relative proportions of these materials used in the production of pewter buttons has a lot to do with how well they held up in various environments.
 

A bunch of nice finds there Jon! Contrary to your experience, I haven't had much luck with pewters coming from a salt water beach as they're generally in poor shape although an occasional nice one appears now and then. I'm leaning toward what Brad said, and maybe the composition of the pewter is the key factor. Pewter was generally comprised of more than 90% tin with much smaller amounts of copper and antimony added as hardening agents, and sometimes a little lead which darkens the appearance. I'm sure the relative proportions of these materials used in the production of pewter buttons has a lot to do with how well they held up in various environments.

Always appreciate you perspective and expertise Bill, curious though that the particular conditions of my coastal sites seem to produce pewters in above average condition. This result is consistent across a variety of manufacturers and time frames (PN, American cast shank, british regimental, and 1812 era finds). Composition of the pewter would certainly play a role though
 

Always appreciate you perspective and expertise Bill, curious though that the particular conditions of my coastal sites seem to produce pewters in above average condition. This result is consistent across a variety of manufacturers and time frames (PN, American cast shank, british regimental, and 1812 era finds). Composition of the pewter would certainly play a role though

Here's a spread of the early pewters, all dug in similar condition despite the diversity of age and manufacture

20160720_193100.webp
 

Very nice hunt, that button is in pristine shape for pewter, doesn't get any better.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom