The first PROBLEM is the lady who began this whole "mess" by buying a detector and using it one day. How many of us can honestly say we found a Treasure the first day we bought a detector. NONE, no way. The only way it's even possible to accomplish this is by YEARS of research prior to the purchase. Then, the odds may go up slightly.
So, for her to do an accurate comparison is not possible.
My next comment is that for a Treasure Hunter, we don't expect to walk out and find a Treasure at a local park. Where did she hunt? Did she even know how to operate the machine? How many of us were experts with our "new" machines the day we bought it?
I have been hunting for approximately 15 (or so) years and have found a Cache. Would I have EVER found it without a detector. No possible way. Have I found a Cache without a detector. No possible way.
Next, what is "her" definition of "Treasure". A penny? A Gold Coin? A Chest full of Pirate Loot?
The History of the Research can even be considered a Treasure.
Just venting and giving my opinion.
xXx