🔎 UNIDENTIFIED Clay pipe stamped "Scotland" on stem with letters "T" & "D" on bowl. How old?

FreeBirdTim

Silver Member
Sep 24, 2013
3,801
6,814
Scituate, RI
🥇 Banner finds
1
Detector(s) used
Garrett AT Pro
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Too tired to take a decent picture, but I found a clay pipe in a bottle dump yesterday. Has "Scotland" stamped into the stem and what looks like the letters "T" and "D" on the bowl. Part of the stem has broken off, but it's about 90% complete. Can anyone give me a date range on this pipe? I'll try to post pics later today to help ID the pipe.
 

pepperj

Gold Member
Feb 3, 2009
38,036
141,568
🥇 Banner finds
1
Detector(s) used
Deus, Deus 2, Minelab 3030, E-Trac,
Primary Interest:
Relic Hunting

Stems Assessing the stems is often a useful first step, since they tend to be the most numerous class of pipe fragment recovered. They can be used to indicate whether a context group is likely to contain residual material, or whether it represents a coherent and potentially tightly dated group. They can also be used to check any dates provided by associated bowl forms, marks or decoration, which can be especially useful for smaller contexts where only a few such pieces are present. There are always exceptions but, in broad terms, stems can usually be allocated to one of three general date ranges by assessing their form, stem bore, fabric and finish. Note that stem bores are still recorded in 64ths of an inch, so as to allow them to be compared with previous records and for the data to be used with stem bore dating techniques developed in the USA (see ‘stem bores’ below).

Seventeenth to Early Eighteenth Century Stems Pipes at this period generally had medium length straight stems (never curved) that were quite thick at the bowl junction. As a result, fragments usually show a clear taper along their length and can be quite chunky if the fragment comes from near the bowl. Stem bores were generally large at this period and so normally range from about 9/65” to 7/64”, with a few pieces of 6/64”. Some pipes were burnished during this period and many areas of the Midlands and northern England exploited local clays, where these were available. A fine sandy fabric was used in the Oxford area and pipes from areas with access to the Coal Measures often employed clays with opaque white gritty inclusions in them. Stems of this period are usually plain and unmarked although occasionally pieces with bands of milled decoration or alternate pinching to create a ‘barley twist’ effect are found. Stem stamps are only rarely found.
barley
Seventeenth and early eighteenth-century stems showing bands of milling (1) and 'barley twist' decoration (2 and 3). Photo D. A. Higgins.​
Late Seventeenth to Late Eighteenth Century Stems Pipes during this period normally had quite long stems but were thinner at the bowl junction than previously. As a result, they are generally rather cylindrical in appearance with less evidence of any stem taper. Stem bores are sometimes as large as 7/64” but more typically in the 6/64” to 5/64” range. Burnishing was still used in some areas, but very rarely in the far south west, the south east and East Anglia. Local clays with inclusions were rarely used after about 1710. Stems were straight until the late eighteenth century when curved varieties were introduced. Milled bands of decoration were still occasionally used at the start of this period but maker’s stamps become more common. Initials or full name marks placed across the top of the stem were most frequently employed in central southern England and the West Midlands, while decorative stem borders were most often employed in the Midlands and north. Long line name and place stamps orientated along the top of the stem were used in the North West region during the late eighteenth century.
Late Eighteenth Century and Later Stems Pipes of this period were all made from fine clays without any obvious inclusions and they typically had stem bores of 5/64” to 4/64”. The stems were normally thinner than previously and varied in length, with nipple type mouthpieces being used on some types after about 1850. Long stems were sometimes rather oval in cross section and could be curved. Burnishing was rarely used, although it continued to be a characteristic of pipes from the Shropshire industry and on some high quality pieces from elsewhere. Stamped marks, now typically orientated along the stem, continued to be used in the West Midlands and North West but died out in other areas in favour of moulded marks. Moulded marks or pattern numbers on the sides of the stem were introduced around the middle of the nineteenth century and became the most widespread and common form of marking thereafter.
pattern
Nineteenth-century moulded pattern number on the side of a stem reading No128. Photo D. A. Higgins.​
Stem Bores Note that stem bores are still measured using Imperial 64ths of an inch. The most common method is to use the butt ends of a set of Imperial drill bits, although a finely gradated ruler or other measuring devices can also be used. Retaining this unit of measurement ensures that any new data is comparable with previously published material. It also allows the date of larger assemblages to be calculated using the stem bore dating formulae that have been developed in the USA. Stem bore dating is not, however, generally used by European archaeologists since it requires a large sample and a lot of work to produce a single date, which does not provide a very sensitive means of assessing either the duration of occupation on a given site or fluctuations of finds use/deposition within that span. There are also a number of concerns over how reliable any date arrived at actually is. Stem bores can, however, be used for distributional plots or as bar graphs to show changing site use over time. The divisions provided by 64ths of an inch make convenient units to express this sort of data. The fractions of an inch are always given in 64ths, and not rationalised to larger alternative units (e.g., it is always 4/64” and not 1/16”).
 

Last edited:
Upvote 4

pepperj

Gold Member
Feb 3, 2009
38,036
141,568
🥇 Banner finds
1
Detector(s) used
Deus, Deus 2, Minelab 3030, E-Trac,
Primary Interest:
Relic Hunting
pipe-id.jpg
 

Upvote 8

Red-Coat

Gold Member
Dec 23, 2019
5,284
16,638
Surrey, UK
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Good information above.

Pipes with ‘T’ and ‘D’ on the bowl were made by McDougall's of Glasgow, Scotland and usually also carry the word ‘McDOUGALL’, plus often numbers for the mould/model number. The company was in operation from 1848 (possibly as early as 1846) all the way through to 1967. However, they dominated the Colonial (and other) export markets in the later half of the 19th Century and pipes which also include a ‘SCOTLAND’ mark (rather than a ‘GLASGOW’ mark, or no geographic mark) usually date after 1891.

It’s not known for sure what the letters T and D stood for, but it has been suggested they were for one of the company managers: Thomas Davidson Jr. That may or may not be true. However, what is true, is that the ‘TD’ indication became a generic for good quality kaolin pipes to the extent that it was ‘borrowed’ by other companies cashing in on McDougall’s reputation. When there is no indication for McDougall, such pipes may have been produced by another maker, but would date sometime after McDougall had established itself as a quality maker.
 

Upvote 7

TORRERO

30+ YEARS, XP DEUS I & II ARE MY GO TO MACHINES
Nov 17, 2004
1,719
1,144
NC
Detector(s) used
XP DEUS I & II
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Has anyone ever dug a brass pipe ? I dug an old brass pipe years ago in a field in Spain, clearly hand carved, no stem but obviously you would put the stem in it and smoke something ? I don't have a picture right now but might dig through my collect and try to find one.
 

Upvote 0

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Top