sandchip
Silver Member
- #1
Thread Owner
...and I ain't superstitious, but as Christine McVie would say, "But I'm beginning to wonder why."
My son and I were in the living room this evening, eating supper and watching TV, the usual, when about 10 feet from us, CRASH! (all caps and exclamation point don't seem to capture it here). 2 of the 6 metal shelf supports simply sheared off dumping the top shelf and contents on the second shelf and contents. After standing in front of the case, superdumbfounded for a couple of minutes, but worried about further collapse, we were able to slip in an old Nazareth Hair of the Dog record and cover (it's what I blindly grabbed out of a dark closet) to keep the bottles on edge from falling off as I opened the door on the right. Already sick from what I could see, it only got worse as I started pulling bottles out, working my way across to the left side. The casualties are pretty bad and I'll post pictures of the KIAs later on. I was really hesitant to post this, because believe me, I really don't want to hear any smartass comments or Monday morning quarterbacking, etc. The shelves were far from overloaded. In that crystal clear hindsight, I guess I should've had the cast metal (probably Chinese pot metal) X-rayed for flaws when I bought the case 15 years ago, right? But seriously, check to see if you have that type and replace with the steel ones. Take as many lessons as you can from my misfortune. It's as freak as I could imagine with the shelf load tight against the uprights, not out there towards the end to give any leverage at all to stress the support where it was inserted. Damned bad, but it could've been so much worse had the shelves pancaked all the way to the bottom. There's no undoing things, so all I can do is look forward, while counting my many, many blessings.

My son and I were in the living room this evening, eating supper and watching TV, the usual, when about 10 feet from us, CRASH! (all caps and exclamation point don't seem to capture it here). 2 of the 6 metal shelf supports simply sheared off dumping the top shelf and contents on the second shelf and contents. After standing in front of the case, superdumbfounded for a couple of minutes, but worried about further collapse, we were able to slip in an old Nazareth Hair of the Dog record and cover (it's what I blindly grabbed out of a dark closet) to keep the bottles on edge from falling off as I opened the door on the right. Already sick from what I could see, it only got worse as I started pulling bottles out, working my way across to the left side. The casualties are pretty bad and I'll post pictures of the KIAs later on. I was really hesitant to post this, because believe me, I really don't want to hear any smartass comments or Monday morning quarterbacking, etc. The shelves were far from overloaded. In that crystal clear hindsight, I guess I should've had the cast metal (probably Chinese pot metal) X-rayed for flaws when I bought the case 15 years ago, right? But seriously, check to see if you have that type and replace with the steel ones. Take as many lessons as you can from my misfortune. It's as freak as I could imagine with the shelf load tight against the uprights, not out there towards the end to give any leverage at all to stress the support where it was inserted. Damned bad, but it could've been so much worse had the shelves pancaked all the way to the bottom. There's no undoing things, so all I can do is look forward, while counting my many, many blessings.

Amazon Forum Fav 👍
Last edited: