Well, the one on the left is certainly real, but I am guessing you probably already knew that. The one on the right appears to just be a cool button based on what I am seeing; the font is different, and cruder than the real one. The design also gives off a cast look to it, and looks much sloppier than on real examples. The material of it also looks more like pot metal rather than silver. I hope I am wrong with this assessment though, good luck.