Did a box of nickels this evening with my wife. She found a 45P war nickel. I found my first Buffalo a 1936. Pretty stoked. Also found a few decent looking 40's-50's nickels.
Great finds! I remember how stoked I was with my first Buffalo, and I still love warnics, too. And good job getting the wife involved early. It'll make it easier for you to justify your imminent addiction.