What's new

New to CRH. Could use some tips.

Legitlyfree

Greenie
Joined
Oct 19, 2011
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
Golden Thread
0
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Hi everyone, my name is Nick and I'm twenty-two years old. My father and I have always been in to coin collecting, but when our house got robbed years ago, the hobby just fell apart. Now we're trying to start again with the little that we have, but with a twist. That's where this comes in. I went to the bank two days ago to get $100 in dimes as I've heard this was a good source of silver. I managed to pull one out of those. Most of what I've read tells me that people average 1.25 dimes per box, so considering my luck, I went to a different bank branch of my bank and got a box of dimes. Completely skunked. After that, I went back to the other branch where I pulled the rosie and asked for another box. The teller said she didn't have a whole box, but she did have about $100 in dimes in her drawer. I took that and got another $150 in quarters. Skunked, again. My dad spent $200 at three different banks and two grocery stores on dimes and quarters, also pulling nothing. I managed to get some information from the teller at my bank. She said that her and her grandfather search halves and dollars, then proceeded to tell me that she had $50 worth of halves in the vault. I was going to ask for them, but seeing as how she was very friendly about it and gave me a little information, I decided to let them go. The next day, they were gone. :P One bank my dad went to offered to order him a box of dollar coins, not the Sacagawea or presidential dollars. We plan on going back to ask about a box of halves. Another bank told us that people come in all the time and ask for halves. Kinda sucks, but what can ya do? :dontknow: So far out of all the places we've been to, they've all been rolled by what looks to be the same company. All by N.F. String & Company in Pennsylvania. Does anyone have any experience with them or tips they can offer on the hobby? It's kind of discouraging not getting anything out of over $700 worth, but getting one out of $100. Also, does anyone have any experience with Arvest banks? That's where I bank and where I got that dime. Oh and if we start getting halves and whole dollars, where do we dump them? Also, what about CWR? Should I go for those instead? After reading some of these threads, I see that most people just spend them, but the money we have is what we plan on using over and over. Buying then dumping. Thanks for all of your help and I apologize for such a long thread.
 
Upvote 0
First off, ALWAYS buy as many half dollars as you can afford. passing on that $50 worth of halves was a bad call. you can dump any coin anywhere you have a bank, and NEVER expect silver to show up simply because you bought "x amount"... never works. Each bank is different, the amount of silver doesnt come from one source, it is completely random... there are no secrets of this trade.
 
Thanks for the replies! Brendan, I really wanted to, but the teller told me her grandfather is there every time they get a new shipment, so I assumed he had returned them there or that she had or was going to go through them. Divulging quite a bit of information, I decided just to let them go as a nice gesture. As for the rolls, does String hand roll or machine roll? Should I order those halves from the other bank? How many boxes a week should I try for? BuffaloBoy, I read all of that besides some of the grading scale, thanks for the help!
 
if a bank has half dollars. wether it is one... or 1000 dollars always try and get them you never know what could happen
 
Legitlyfree,
Welcome to the site! I wish you and your father the best in your searches, and I hope you are able to re-build your coin collection in your searching.

What follows are just my observations, I hope you find them useful.

I second brendan1414 and AGBlex on the recommendation that you pull on halves. They will produce the best results for silver from my experience. They don't circulate, so there is more silver left in bags and vaults in the half dollar denomination than in any other. Having said that, if you are trying to build your coin collection and you want to focus on smaller denominations, then by all means pull on those too. Just keep in mind that you get a higher pay-off with halves. I also note that halves give me a variety of collectibles -- S-Mints, error coins, old silver (only one Barber, but I've pulled a good number of Walker's and Ben's in addition to Ken's), commemoratives old and new, and foreign coins. :icon_sunny:

So my best wishes, treat the tellers nicely and make friends. Life is a journey and building relationships with the folks you are in contact with will always pay dividends. :angel5:

Steve
 
Steve L. said:
Legitlyfree,
Welcome to the site! I wish you and your father the best in your searches, and I hope you are able to re-build your coin collection in your searching.

What follows are just my observations, I hope you find them useful.

I second brendan1414 and AGBlex on the recommendation that you pull on halves. They will produce the best results for silver from my experience. They don't circulate, so there is more silver left in bags and vaults in the half dollar denomination than in any other. Having said that, if you are trying to build your coin collection and you want to focus on smaller denominations, then by all means pull on those too. Just keep in mind that you get a higher pay-off with halves. I also note that halves give me a variety of collectibles -- S-Mints, error coins, old silver (only one Barber, but I've pulled a good number of Walker's and Ben's in addition to Ken's), commemoratives old and new, and foreign coins. :icon_sunny:

So my best wishes, treat the tellers nicely and make friends. Life is a journey and building relationships with the folks you are in contact with will always pay dividends. :angel5:

Steve

Thank you very much, this site is full of information and knowledgeable people. We went back today to speak to the two friendly tellers that were there before. Apparently some man came in and dumped a few loose ones in her tray in exchange for bills. After looking through them, she and her friend pulled 16 silvers. :'( Great for her though! She gave us much more information and told us how we can ask other banks for their bags from the coin counter and everything. I'm glad these two are at the branch I bank at, it makes things much easier. We just bought all she had, another $450 fed rolled, so we'll see how that goes and I'll post the results!
 
Welcome to the forum, its the best one around.

I think you should get the Ike box if you can, I have read CRH'ers make 30% premium on them over craigslist.

I agree with the rest of the more experience CRH'ers above. One thing I might add is that buying is easy, dump them is the hard part.
 
Always buy the halfs. Now dont expect to find silver all the time. if you do large amounts of coin you will find silver. You just have to keep looking. HH and welcome to the game.
 
Well, the results are in! We got $450 worth and split them up. Unfortunately, for me, I found nothing. He however, found two 40%er's a 1969-D and a 1966. We'll be going to the other bank tomorrow and asking about those boxes and seeing if they cost anything to order them. Should we get as many boxes as we can a week? Thanks everyone!
 
I'd just like to say, that over my 6 months of CRHing, I've pulled things like 1 Silver out of $15 in Dimes, 3 Silvers out of $100 in Dimes, and 2 40%s in $70 of Halves. I've also had a day where I searched more than I weigh in Halves and Dimes with no Silver. As well as pretty much anything and everything in between.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom