I hated mine for at least a month, but man do I love it now. Especially with the 5x8 coil. Ergonomically the 5x8 makes it feel like a whole new machine. I rely on what I hear 98% of the time, rather than the display. But of course I run in Pro Mode, zero iron disc, no notching. I WANT to hear everything. The display could be smaller for all I care, wouldn't matter to me. For your price range and for use in water I'd go with the ATPro. Even if you don't end up liking the ATPro, it has great resale value. I would give it more than 45 minute before coming to a conclusion though.