Plains Arrow Shaft Abraders

11KBP

Hero Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2008
Messages
792
Reaction score
1,147
Golden Thread
0
Location
Central Great Plains
Seeing the recent post concerning the abrading tool I thought I would make a post specifically describing the Late Prehistoric arrow shaft abraders:

Shaft Abraders - Plains matched pair style

Arrow Shaft Abraders
Central Plains Tradition:
Circa A.D. 1100 to 1450


The distribution range of this type of arrow shaft abrader, sometimes called arrow shaft smoothers (not to be confused with straighteners), is primarily in the Great Plains region consisting of the Dakotas, Nebraska, Kansas and Oklahoma but have also been found in neighboring states. They appear to be most common on Central Plains Tradition sites. These abraders are always made of sandstone with one of the common sources being Dakota sandstone which outcrops in both Nebraska and Kansas.

The shaft abraders shown in the images below were made and utilized by the same Late Prehistoric cultures that made the Fresno, Washita, Harrell and Huffaker arrow points as well as the distinctive Plains Harahey Knife.

The first image is a group of damaged arrow shaft abraders, many of these are found in this condition as oftentimes the sandstone used was not very durable and therefore the abraders will break fairly easy.
SA1.webp


The second and third images are of a matched set of shaft abraders found in 1976 by Merle Stevens, a Nebraska collector. The arrow shaft is held in one hand and sandwiched between the two sandstone abraders which are held together with the other hand. The shaft is then drawn back and forth through the paired abraders to obtain the desired evenness and smoothness.

SA2.webp


SA3.webp


As can be seen in the next two images the shaft abraders vary in length and there can also some variance in shape, some having more rounded boat-shaped surfaces and some with more squared surfaces. The bottom example has had the groove etched in but has seen very little use or possibly not used at all.

SA4.webp


SA5.webp


Shaft Abrader Preforms:
The two pieces in the below images are shaft abrader preforms for making matched pairs of arrow shaft abraders. The sandstone preforms can vary somewhat in shape. They were first formed into a shape similar to these two examples shown here.

SA6.webp


The below picture is of another preform (found in several pieces) and this one was in the process of being cut in half. This example was generously given to me by Lyle Nickel, an Oklahoma collector who knew of my interest in these unique tools.

SA7a.webp


The last image is of a replication I did after a well-know Plains/High Plains authenticator told me that the pieces I was calling preforms was not likely correct and was the reason I decided to attempt a replication.
After photo-documenting my experiment he decided I had a good point and apologized.

SA8 Abrader Replication.webp
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Excellent post and exactly what I was saying. I have half of a set, and it suffered a lot of water erosion, since it was in a river. I know of Lyle Nickel. We hunted in many of the same areas he did, and he always seemed to beat us to them. One time we found a perfect Washita point he missed. It was in one of his boot prints, haha!
 
Excellent post and exactly what I was saying. I have half of a set, and it suffered a lot of water erosion, since it was in a river. I know of Lyle Nickel. We hunted in many of the same areas he did, and he always seemed to beat us to them. One time we found a perfect Washita point he missed. It was in one of his boot prints, haha!
No matter how good you are, you can’t see everything! I walked right past a nice 6” preform in a creek bed full of rocks. My hunting partner was right behind me and grabbed it. He still razzes me about it.🤣
 
Once again 11KBP, that was one of the more informative posts I've seen on here. Only reason I knew anything about it was cause people smarter than me told me. I never met Lyle Nickel, but my ace hunting partner Glenn Sipes told me that's who it was beating us to all those sites. I think he had a brother who was also a big collector. I was in a college class with a guy named Lyle Nickel, probably not the same guy, but I'm kicking myself for never once asking him "Hey, do you hunt arrowheads?"
 
Once again 11KBP, that was one of the more informative posts I've seen on here. Only reason I knew anything about it was cause people smarter than me told me. I never met Lyle Nickel, but my ace hunting partner Glenn Sipes told me that's who it was beating us to all those sites. I think he had a brother who was also a big collector. I was in a college class with a guy named Lyle Nickel, probably not the same guy, but I'm kicking myself for never once asking him "Hey, do you hunt arrowheads?"
Thank you RGINN.

Yes, that is the same artifact hunter/collector. Lyle has one of the finest collections of artifacts found in the Central Great Plains region that I am aware of.
 
Even though they didn’t have them in my area I enjoyed reading your post.
Glad you enjoyed the post CreekSide.
It is a fairly short window of time that the matched pair style of arrow shaft abraders were being made by Late Prehistoric NA’s. Finding an intact matched pair is a very rare find and hardly ever seen in Plains collections. Some of the best undamaged pairs I have seen came out of professionally excavated house sites of the Central Plains Tradition culture.
 
That is a great post. I wonder how many cultures besides the ones you mentioned may have used a similar tool? It would seem a necessary item to anyone making arrows. Form follows function so maybe. I've never found anything remotely close to those. Thanks for the information.
 
I love to see info like this. Thanx for posting it.
When I was about 10 we were camping at the lake. I was on the beach looking for fossils and throwing rocks. I found an Indian marble and one abrader stone exactly like the ones in the lower right corner of the display pictured. I knew it was altered by man but had no idea it was of NA origin. In the lake it went. When we started school that fall we took a field trip to the local NA village museum and I saw some on display and my heart sank. Ever since then, I keep even the most questionable pieces for further study. I have not found an abrader since but still have the Indian marble
 
That is a great post. I wonder how many cultures besides the ones you mentioned may have used a similar tool? It would seem a necessary item to anyone making arrows. Form follows function so maybe. I've never found anything remotely close to those. Thanks for the information.
Thank you newnan man.
I have seen other shaft abrading stones but not in the matched pair configuration.
 
I love to see info like this. Thanx for posting it.
When I was about 10 we were camping at the lake. I was on the beach looking for fossils and throwing rocks. I found an Indian marble and one abrader stone exactly like the ones in the lower right corner of the display pictured. I knew it was altered by man but had no idea it was of NA origin. In the lake it went. When we started school that fall we took a field trip to the local NA village museum and I saw some on display and my heart sank. Ever since then, I keep even the most questionable pieces for further study. I have not found an abrader since but still have the Indian marble
You are welcome Jatrox.
I liked your abrader find story.
Was your “local NA village museum” the one in these images?

Kansas 14RP1 a.webp


Kansas 14RP1 h.webp


I have helped at this site (Kansas 14RP1) on occasions when they needed some locations checked with a metal detector.

Kansas 14RP1.webp


Kansas 14RP1 e.webp
 
Last edited:
You are welcome Jatrox.
I liked your abrader find story.
Was your “local NA village museum” the one in these images?

That's the one. I wish there were more sites like it. There is so much NA history in the plains it's crazy. Very cool that you got to work there.
There are abrader stones in situ on the floor of that museum. I still beat myself up for tossing the one I found in the lake.
 

Attachments

  • abraders 2.webp
    abraders 2.webp
    233.1 KB · Views: 10

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom