Question: What is the most valuable single coin youve pulled from circulation?

[SFBayArea]

Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

Out of curiousity.. what is the single most valuable coin you've pulled from circulation or paid face value for?

Mine was a 1921 Peace Dollar I got years ago...
As for best in pennies: 1922 Canadian Penny low mintage
As for best in halves: None more than silver content value ... Never gotten a Barber in 10 years of searching.
(Updated 2/16/10 - did find a 1901 very worn Barber two weeks ago (AG-03))
As for best in dimes: 1927-S in VF condition
As for best in nickels: Don't search nickels
As for best in quarters: Don't search quarters

Notables although not extremely rare or valuable (all circulated)
1892 Columbian Expo Half Dollar
1986-S Ellis Island Half Dollar
1994-D World Cup Half Dollar
1992-S Olympics Half Dollar

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Cry Of The Eagle: History And Legends Of The Cherokee Indians And Their Buried Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[SFBayArea]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

That's a nice 1938-D.. I don't have that date.. It looks like it's a Extra Fine condition. Nice Haul..

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Family Maps of Hinds County, Mississippi, Deluxe Edition - Grab it through Amazon!

[SFBayArea]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

Maine_Jim,.. Great 1920 Maine Commemorative.. I haven't gotten a silver commerative to date.. I've gotten two Ellis Island 1986-S but that's it... would love to get a old time silver commemorative like that

 

[golden silver]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

1945 walker in AU condition. 1970d and s. 1916 mercury dime that I think is a d but it is really worn extremely hard to tell.

Golden Silver

 

[mistergee]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

1909s penny probably worth 50$?

same

 

[phrostie]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

I remember that TF that was a good one! Back to searching boxes with winter on the brink?

I'd say my best is probably a 1970 half or 1892 Columbian Expo half...you be the judge!

 

[GMan00001]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

Pennies... 1992-D close AM unsure of its value as I can't find one for sale, but judging by the PCGS prices I did ok...

Also 1924-D and 1914-S pennies, 1909 VDB(x5?) and a few others I am forgetting about as I am just doing this from memory.

nickels... 1950-D(x2), 1883 No Cents V Nickel

dimes... nothing particularly valuable though I have found a couple barbers.

quarters... nothing particularly valuable some from the 30's and a 1958 that is pretty low mintage if I remember right.

halves... a couple barber halves, 1970-D, and a couple of earlier walkers that I don't remember the date of, but not as rare as 1938-D from what I remember.

dollars... nothing to speak of...all Ikes or newer.

 

[3xflyfisher]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

Hi all,
I used to own a bulk vending(gumball machines) business and found quite a few silver quarters. The best was a 32s in vf condition. The were several other silver coins in that machine that day so I think some kid got into his dads collection and bought gumballs!
Regards,
3xflyfisher

 

[treasurefiend]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

I remember that TF that was a good one! Back to searching boxes with winter on the brink?

I'd say my best is probably a 1970 half or 1892 Columbian Expo half...you be the judge!

1892 Columbian Expo half - All the way!!!!

 

[50centman]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

1921d in F12 condition about a year ago. Nearly fell off my chair. Did about a quadruple take.

 

[mebegene]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

1916D Obv Walker
1996S Soccer Proof - Atlanta Olympics
1864L Indian Head - VF (3 days ago)
1914D Lincoln (3 days ago)
1876S Seated Liberty Half-Dollar
1920D Fine Walker
1913 D .01
1911 P VF .01
1919 S VF .01
1946 S Booker T Washington
1900 Great Britain (Queen Victoria) Penny
1940 Unc .01
85 Barbers .50
...and oh yes approx $15,000.00 in silver bullion since getting into the 'roll-racket' in earnest in 2000.


Mebegene

 

[SFBayArea]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

Mebegene.. how many boxes do you get a week to get 15k in silver in ten years? that's alot..

 

[cedarratt]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

Wisconsin Low leaf Error quarter. Got it in change and sold it for 76$ on ebay.

 

[fiddycent]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

found a few cool coins.

1858-O Seated Liberty half dollar

1875 Seated Liberty dime

1873 One Florin coin (British) in F-VF condition (maybe better)

1945 Two Shilling coin (British) looks like it was cleaned....oh well.

Bi-Centennial Ike Proof dollar

10 1970-D halves

7 1970-S halves

2-Franklin Proof halves '62 & '63.

This hobby was great fun and I may start up again. I miss the thrill of the chase!

GOOD LUCK ALL!

 

[treasurefiend]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

bump

 

[50centman]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

1921d Walker in F12 condition. Nearly fell off my chair when I saw it in the roll. I think I did at least a tripple take.

 

[snake35]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

How come I never find anything cool?

 

[Yinzi50]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

1925 Stone Mountain

 

[timbobwey]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

Mine is probobly the 1945 walker I got like 3 weeks ago, AU condition.

 

[cdickrun64]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulati

82 no p dime

 

[Kantuckkeean]

Re: Question: What is the most valuable single coin you've pulled from circulation?

Most valuable. Possibly a wrong planchet error. I found a quarter that is wrong diameter, wrong weight, wrong material, wrong thickness, and the reeding is screwed up. Could be a worthless counterfeit.

1939D nickel in sweet condition (a couple steps).

My wife found a 1912 V nickel with a mint mark. I can't tell if it's the S or not though. Should I nick-a-date it?

Kindest regards,
Kantuck