Should I pull the trigger?

[PAScott]

I currently have an ATPro and really do love it; however, I've been considering getting a CTX 3030. I mostly hunt a freshwater lake, some tot lots, and sports fields in my area. I get to the beach for a week or so every year. Normally Ocean City Maryland or the Outer Banks. My ATPro has done well in the dry sand but I would like to get into the water or wet sand this year. I usually am able to get out for 3-4 hours once or twice a week. Daily for about 4 hours when at the beach.

The main thing stopping me is the money. Is it worth it? Will I be happy after spending so much? Anyone else make this jump? I would love to hear your thoughts. Also thoughts on buying new vs used and where to buy? Thanks in advance on your thoughts.

 

[DeepseekerADS]

I need a water setup.

Yep!

I remember in '84 I lived in NE Ohio just a brisk walk from the Lake Erie beaches. I swung a land machine, even looked over at the beach while hitting a playground. I did dig a merc under the canopy of a small tree. Then as I was leaving heading to my next project, one of the treasure mags front cover was about a NE Ohio hunter who found 140 gold rings in a season. Sure wish I could find that article now.

I ended up leaving the hobby for a few years, worked heavy overtime 90-100 hrs a week for too long, lost my wife to that too.

But as I was ramping up to retirement, I wanted something very very good so I could get out on my knees again. First I bought an ACE250, then an Etrac, and then moved up to the CTX.

Remembering that magazine cover, I started reading a ton of beach & water threads here. Just wanted to get a clear and honest direction to go. Other water machines appealed to me, but I went in the direction of the Excal II. Of course there's no screen, you don't need a screen. You're looking for that solid signal. The Excal finds that for you

 

[Liu21]

Excal II, and take some of that money and spend it on upgrades, a nice sand digger etc....

 

[DeepseekerADS]

Look at the stuff I have on the left.
It's all sitting still now, almost abandoned, since I got my 3030.

Yep, I got to watch my friend G.I.B. on the beach in St. Pete. When we arrived I went down in the water with my Excal. He set up a test spot burying different rings, and listening to the signals and looking at the numbers. He was really getting into it!

And then after about an hour he proceeded to hunt the sand while I was shoulder deep in the water, and kicked my butt

CTX lives!

 

[DeepseekerADS]

The idea of a $2500 machine leaking does scare me. It also sounds like minelab may be a little less customer service friendly then what I'm used to with Garrett. Not saying it is because I would not know. Just have read a few concerning posts.

From personal experience, I've had my CTX, my Etrac, and my Excal repaired by the repair center. Two of my problems with the machines were my own fault, and one was a defective machine I bought from the For Sale forums here and had it shipped straight for repair. Those are great guys there, and they care about what they are doing. The absolute issue is in repair parts shipping from Asia with 4 month lead times on ships. Minelab Corp needs to discover express air.

 

[DeepseekerADS]

Excal II, and take some of that money and spend it on upgrades, a nice sand digger etc....

Begone elbow pain! Mod it with a straight shaft with the controls behind your elbow and you can go all day long with zero discomfort!

 

[cudamark]

Thanks for the info tcornel! I figure it will take me a while to get used to it. I've liked the ATPro because it wasn't too complicated. Hope if I get a ctx I will have the patience for the learning curve. Sounds like the book is a must. Lack of display is my concern with excalibur since I'm used to one now.

For land/park/turf hunting, I would agree that you would want a meter for target I.D. and depth. At the beach, it really isn't an issue. You can discriminate out iron, so, all you have left is non-ferrous, which you will scoop, right?

 

[beerguy]

Begone elbow pain! Mod it with a straight shaft with the controls behind your elbow and you can go all day long with zero discomfort!

I am in process of modding an older 800 Excal with the travel shaft from plugger. Carbon fiber and light as a feather.

 

[RustyGold]

The Carbon Fiber shafts from Bill (Plugger) is a must have mod on the Excal. You can swing it for hours.

 

[Escape]

When I'm undecided for a long time, going back and forth. Eventually I just buy what ever it is just to get it out of my system. It will probably be your new go to detector.

 

[Truth]

I did it a couple years ago. The ATP is a great machine for the money but is not is the same class as the CTX. You will have a learning curve but in the end there is no way you will consider going back. I have one up here in Ohio and a second in my condo in Myrtle Beach. Both were bought used with over a years warranty left. If you go the used route be sure to check the serial numbers with Minelab to insure it is genuine product and also to confirm warranty time remaining.

Be sure to buy Sabisch's book. It will cut your learning curve substantially.

The excalibur is sounds only, no digital display which would be quite different than the ATP.

What would you get if you had the AT Pro but needed something better for land? Would you still have the same opinion?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[PAScott]

I upgraded to the 3030 twice and for some reason sold them both and use my Excal in the water and beach.
When I'm only in the sand, wet or dry, I like the sovereign GT.
My AT Pro is for lakes and creeks.
Is it possible you can use a friends CTX to see if you would like it before you lay out the cash?
Best of luck in whatever you decide.

Thanks Rusty Gold.
Great idea unfortunately I don't know anyone with a 3030.
Makes sense certain detectors may be better or one may feel more comfortable in certain situations/conditions.

 

[PAScott]

For land/park/turf hunting, I would agree that you would want a meter for target I.D. and depth. At the beach, it really isn't an issue. You can discriminate out iron, so, all you have left is non-ferrous, which you will scoop, right?

Makes sense and yes!

 

[DeepseekerADS]

I wasn't going to advertise, but I went with the Plugger straight shaft, and now I'm looking at buying another My second Excal.

 

[tcornel]

What would you get if you had the AT Pro but needed something better for land? Would you still have the same opinion?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I had the ATP and sold it. The CTX is top of the line on land, fresh water and salt water. I think I saw an ad in our classified's for a ctx including the 300 6" coil for 1600 with about a year's warranty left.

1600 less 450 for the atp leaves an out of pocket of 1150 for the upgrade.

 

[PAScott]

I had the ATP and sold it. The CTX is top of the line on land, fresh water and salt water. I think I saw an ad in our classified's for a ctx including the 300 6" coil for 1600 with about a year's warranty left.

1600 less 450 for the atp leaves an out of pocket of 1150 for the upgrade.

Thanks, I saw the ad too. Thought about looking into it. Want to make sure it is newer model with the updated battery compartment seals.

 

[tcornel]

Both of mine are the old style. Using the new grey o rings there are not any issues.

 

[PAScott]

Thanks tcornel.

 

[PAScott]

Well I did it i pulled the trigger and bought a new ctx. Let the learning begin.

 

[Truth]

Both of mine are the old style. Using the new grey o rings there are not any issues.

The battle royal going on in my mine CTX vs XP? That price on that CTX gives me sticker shock. Ugggh. It's funny the years I've spent learning " the game within the game" of the ATP and then come to the realization it's not that good. Lol I'd like to continue on another machine with similar number reading. Well maybe one with more distinguishing tone between pulltab and gold. Any suggestions tcprnel?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[relic nut]

Well I did it i pulled the trigger and bought a new ctx. Let the learning begin.

Hey PAScott, I just went from the Atp to the CTX. The learning curve is not as bad as you think. Understand, it does take time but you will find stuff right out of the gate. If you don't have Andy's book (CTX 3030 handbook) get it and study it hard. It has helped me tremendously! He puts it in plan English and if you already know how to detect it will make sense. Get the machine in your hand and play with the controls until you can move around with confidence. (I drove my wife crazy) once you learn what the settings do and how to get to them then your detecting experience will kick in. Like I said, I've got a ways to go but I already feel confidence in the machine and for me that's half the battle. Good luck and let us know how it goes.

HH RN