I have always wondered about the Filson connection to the Swift story...the oldest document professing the Swift Silver mine is real.
In 1788 John FIlson and Robert Breckenridge file a land entry for a 1000 acre square tract laid on the cardinal points (N S E W) around a mine worked by a man named Swift. At said mine, Swift reports he has extracted from the ore a considerable quantity of silver, some of which he made into dollars... The location being some 60 or 70 miles from Martin's Cabbin. This was the first of a four step process in obtaining a land grant.
The questions i present are these.
1). Who was Robert Breckenridge and what was his interest in the silver?
2). "Swift reports he has extracted from the ore a considerable quantity of silver"
a). Sounds to me like this infers there were other metals extracted from the ore as well. Was this a lead operation and a considerable amount of silver was extracted also?
b). This also infers that Filson or Breckenridge has spoken with Swift "Swift reports..."
Some 5 years later ... in 1793, Col. James Harrod, who founded Harrod's Station, the first settlement in KY in 1774, disappeared (died) near the three forks of the Ky River (near present day Beattyville, KY) looking for Swift's Silver mine.
3). Who were the two men that accompanied Harrod on this search for Swift's mine? One is named, the other is not in every account I can find.
These questions I ask because the answers may reveal clues to the truth beneath the legend. If anyone knows anything please leave an answer here in the this thread.
https://ed-henson.blogspot.com/2011/06/john-filson-and-james-harrod.html
http://vagenweb.org/wise/SilverMines/Uncovered.html