That's a tough one. Can't find anything on the business. Checked to see if there was a museum or chamber of commerce, but nothing. Only found this, Pictorial History of Accident, Maryland - Ruth Enlow Library. So early 1900's maybe late 1800's.
Schenkman's MD Merchant Tokens book shows tokens from Gnagey in 5, 10, & 25 (¢) denominations, but not the 1.00. He says, "John E. Gnagey started operating a general store during the 1870s. He went out of business in the early 1900s." I will let him know about this denomination - would you be willing to post your pics on tokencatalog.com?
John in the Great 208
The 1875 edition of Boyd’s Business Directory for Maryland lists the occupations and businesses in the five largest cities in Maryland, and all the smaller towns.
The book is organized by occupation. John Gnagey of Accident is listed under Agricultural Implements.
Don..........
ok so being the curious type i contacted a family member of the family that lived in farm house on the property i was hunting and she said oh yes honey the people that owned the general store in Accident Md moved here and were related to the family so i told her about the tokens and she said she didnt recall tokens but she still has a couple of the store ledger books packed away somewhere