Very Old Silver... no clue and need ID.

BigWaveDave

Gold Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2013
Messages
9,446
Reaction score
17,696
Golden Thread
2
Location
Mountain Maryland
🥇 Banner finds
2
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
4
Detector(s) used
Garrett AT Pro, AT Max, Minelab
Equinox 800
Primary Interest:
Metal Detecting
It’s very thin, brittle, and has what appears to be hand-etched designs.
Maybe a broken clasp at top? Reverse side maybe a clip or hinge of some sort.

I beat it up a bit...8 inches deep, on its side, beneath a fat root. Apologies to anyone I’ve offended for damaging this relic.

777FDE59-6039-4F9F-A3A8-B634B74C6797.webp37C3F43E-A0B5-452D-AFB9-A322C2F6B38D.webp

No doubt I gave y’all sideways pics again lol

Ok kids....what is it?
 

Upvote 6
I have never seen silver crack like that and I have made silver jewelry for over forty years. Did you use a nitric acid test?

I have had old sterling rings break into pieces. There must be something in the soil that causes them to turn brittle when they have been in the ground a long time. They are definitely silver, but the purity might be less than it should be for sterling.
 

Very nice Dave, my guess would be some kind of brooch, maybe earring, possibly a pocket watch back. But the big question is ; who stuck a Lesche through it???!!!!(;
 

Congrats on the silver! Looks old to me. At first I didn't think it looked like silver but after zooming in I changed my mind. Brooch or possibly some kind of pin or medal?
 

Very nice Dave, my guess would be some kind of brooch, maybe earring, possibly a pocket watch back. But the big question is ; who stuck a Lesche through it???!!!!(;

It wasn’t even the Lesche!
It was on its edge, beneath a fat root in hard, dry packed dirt. Once I saw the edge, I was sure it wasn’t a coin. Once I got a grip on it, I wiggled and pulled it free... that’s how I wrecked it. Lesson learned... don’t find old, fragile silver under roots lol.
 

Very interesting find Dave. It almost looks like a map imposed on another image. I see a tree in front of a lake with trails and a stream going either to or from the lake. I even see what appears to be people near the lake. I hope you find out the answer to this.
 

I have never seen silver crack like that and I have made silver jewelry for over forty years. Did you use a nitric acid test?

I have a silver pocket watch with a cracked case, it happens. Not sure why and I bet you know better, but maybe from work hardening and not being annealed?
 

I was also thinking Pocket Watch cover BWD. I agree with Terry and your early thoughts on the item.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom