I vote banner! The difference between the buttons pictured seems minimal to me. Excellent find! Can you give some details- type of area found in- type of detector ? That had to bring a smile to your face!
Is this the second GW button you have found? Website says you had banner for the same button in 2006? That's incredible if it's your 2nd one. I have heard that people traveled around in the 1700s selling those buttons and they were sold in groups of four- maybe there's 2 more out there!
Yes Fredbug67 , its my second GW button . last one was found in 2008 many miles away from where i got this one .