Here's an update, and I still need advice.
I bought a used Tesoro Vaquero with 2 coils. With a new battery, it finds nothing in this hole. Not with either coil, whether the ground is soaked or bone dry. No matter what I do with the settings. Nothing.
The Bounty Hunter get wild in this hole when the ground is soaked. I can put the sensitivity and discrimination anywhere, and I'll get some kind of repeatable signal in spots. The more I discriminate out, the higher the signal goes. Signals vary when it's damp and I get nothing when it's bone dry.
Other than the hole, they both get signals in all the same spots on property. Today I found a spot in a big piece of solid limestone where they were both getting a signal. I'll never know what that is.
Does this sound like a preset vs manual GB issue? If so, can someone please explain it to me? Thanks.