Whites DFX or Minelab explorer

matters

Jr. Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2009
Messages
44
Reaction score
0
Golden Thread
0
Location
Eastern WV
Detector(s) used
Minelab X-Terra 50
I want to purchase a new detector. I have been looking at them all. Right now I have a minelab x-50 and have made some good finds and enjoy running it. I am looking to upgrade to a dfx or explorer. What are your thought pros and cons of each and expericenes with these detectors. My hunting will mainly consist of coins and relics in moderate mineralized soils, some areas are trashy. Thanks for you thoughts.
 
Upvote 0
Just my two cents, but, I believe the DFX and the Explorer's to be basically on the same level performance wise. We can argue all day on which one gets an extra inch, etc., however, remember that the SPOT you hunt is WAYYYYYYYYYY more important than the detector. As is user experience.

I've used both White's (MXT 300) & Minelab (Safari) and believe both brands to be MORE than sufficient units. All that being said, if you've been using the X-terra already, I'd say stick with Minelab as you don't have to re-learn a new brand :thumbsup:
 
The minelab explorer is superior. I have seen them pitted against each other, time and again, and the explorer spanks the DFX. Just my .02 :headbang:
 
The count in these parts for myself and 10 diggin buds I hunt with and keep in touch with.

Explorer users 11

DFX users 0


There was one DFX but he switched.
 
Isn't there one Whites guy out here to defend the DFX?
 
Go on over to the White's section on here and I'm sure you'll get glowing feedback. Also, try going over to the actual White's forum (just type it in on google) and yet again you'll hear raves.

Believe me when I tell you, they are roughly the same performance wise. As I stated earlier, it is the SPOT wayyyyyyyyyyyyy more than it is the machine. I've used White's before and LOVED them. I know several folks who run with the DFX and they routinely get 12 to 14 inches no problem.

However, again, if you are already used to the Minelab brand, then, just stick with it. But, the DFX is a monster all the way around. Oh yeah, the recovery speed on the White's will blow ANY of the Minelab's OUT OF THE WATER!!! :thumbsup:
 
You also have to factor in, the type target you are aiming for. Because I have heard it said (by some DFX'rs who can't argue with results on the deep silver in the turf), that the DFX is ...... however ..... superior on tweeking for low conductors (ie.: jewelry, etc....). I'm not sure about this, as I don't see many of them on the beaches where I'm at. And if someone WERE to take DFX's out to the turf/land to specifically try to hone in on jewelry and low conductors (IF that were the supposed merit over the Explorer), then it still doesn't make sense to me, because there is NO SHORTAGE of low conductors to find, ANYWHERE on land (not talking relicky hunt sites, for the moment). I mean, think of it: you can go to ANY junky inner-city blighted turfed park, turn on ANY machine, simply lower your disc, and preto, you can dig low conductors till your arms fall off. I can understand the logic on a beach or some specific jewelry hunting application, where to get slightly more teensy chains or something would be the goal. But this is certainly not the objective in turfed parks, where low conductor abound, for any any and all machines.

In any case, I have no trouble on fairly small gold items (barring earing studs, tinsel thin chains, etc...) anyhow with the explorer, provided you are in ferrous, etc... There comes a point for ANY discriminator (particularly power-house depth demon machines) where yeah, you'll start to miss tinsel fine earing studs or whatever. But given the power house than the explorer is, I think it does a decent job at little gold items. Not as good as others perhaps (especially when you're talking all-metal pulse), but good enough for standard discriminator usage, when the desire to pass nails/iron the beach is needed.
 
I have the DFX 300 and love it. Some freinds of mine have Minelabs and love them as well. I can't say which is better. It is like the old ford vs. chevy question. It is more of a preference. They both will do the job. If you have a local dealer for both I would visit and get a hands on and see which one you prefer. You will not go wrong with either choice.
 
My DFX works great...but I would be leery over Minelab service...it keeps me from buying one...
 
Believe me when I tell you, they are roughly the same performance wise.

I agree 100%. I had both the Explorer Se and DFX and in my testing, in Kansas, the SE had an ever so slight depth advantage on silver, but the DFX spanked the SE in every other condition. I sold the SE and still have the DFX. I don't think the SE is really deeper, but it does make hearing the deep silver easier due to it's tones. The DFX could see every coin the SE could see and made jewelry hunting far more pleasant.
 
I have never used an Explorer, but like the look of them....
I have however used a DFX for more than 8 years (I think that is when I got it)
It is a really killer machine if you know how to work it... ( I do )
and I can normally walk circles around a white XLT,
That said, I have heard many good things about the Explorer but Minelabs tend to be heavier
machines to cary around..
 
Most everything else being equal, what do you want more: fast recovery and sensitive to smaller gold (dfx) or the ability to metal detect highly mineralized ground with a powerful tone id(Explorer)? Both are super machines and each has its benefits.
 
Thanks for all the input. I still am not sure which I will end up with. I like them both for different reasons.
 
I've used both at all my favorite sites. My dfx collects dust now, and I'd walk a mile to use the explorer.
 
fistfulladirt said:
I'd walk a mile to use the explorer.


That's not as good as mine.

I'd buy an explorer every year if I had to. ;D
 
Iron Patch said:
fistfulladirt said:
I'd walk a mile to use the explorer.


That's not as good as mine.

I'd buy an explorer every year if I had to. ;D

I got you beat! I have bought an explorer every year for the past 2 years. :tongue3: ;D
 
Explorer waaaaaaaaaaaay better than Whites
 
All you will get on this question is if they use Minelabs they are the best............ If they use whites they are best............Like .. treasurehound.... said like Ford & Chevy If they drive a Ford there are best if they drive a chevy they are best.........
 

Attachments

  • 192x235.webp
    192x235.webp
    13.5 KB · Views: 410
  • 192x235.webp
    192x235.webp
    13.5 KB · Views: 414
treasurehound nailed it. You might want to consider used also. Just find a multiline dealer and try a couple-see what you like.
 
I'm gonna look at the whites today. I like both of them just leaning toward the whites right now. Great customer service and made here in the US. Want to check out the minelab before purchasing though. Thanks again for all the feedback.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom