cleaning indian heads

jonhls

Full Member
Nov 10, 2006
210
1
i have about a dozen ih's i have dug this year and they are all green.is there any way to get rid of the green without chemicals.Most of the im not to worried about but i have a 89 that would be au50 if it wasnt discolored.it is an even green over the whole coin so im not sure how much it reduces the value...any ideas out there ty and hh...jon
 

But they need to be green. That patina is awesome and adds character!! If they are clean, but for the green, I say leave 'em alone. Shiney pennies should be new ones!
Just my 2 cents worth
~Nash~
 

Nashoba said:
But they need to be green. That patina is awesome and adds character!! If they are clean, but for the green, I say leave 'em alone. Shiney pennies should be new ones!
Just my 2 cents worth
~Nash~

Totally agree.
 

Nashoba said:
But they need to be green. That patina is awesome and adds character!! If they are clean, but for the green, I say leave 'em alone. Shiney pennies should be new ones!
Just my 2 cents worth
~Nash~
I agree, if its old , it should look old.
 

I would loooooooooove to able to get rid of the green as well. It would make these 90 indian heads I dug this year worth some actual money. I got some pretty good dates in what I found, but sadly being green takes any significant collector value away from them.
 

bscofield6 said:
I would loooooooooove to able to get rid of the green as well. It would make these 90 indian heads I dug this year worth some actual money. I got some pretty good dates in what I found, but sadly being green takes any significant collector value away from them.

Do you want to collect them or find them? If you want to collect them then buy them, If you want to find them then appreciate the patination.
 

The only thing i would do is use the hydrogen peroxide method. I agree with Nash leave em alone green is good! Olive oil works good but i believe it leeches into the coin and it always looks greasy. Happy hunting!
 

Use nothing but virgin olive oil and a denture tooth brush.It will leave the nice patina and all details will be seen.I once found a beautiful 1907 IH and every letter in liberty was detailed.I tried electrolysis on it and completly ruined it.
 

I soaked one in olive oil and a little dishwater detergent...Left it soak for a few days.....Rinsed it off a little and used a Q-tip to lightly rub some of the dirt off...came out beautiful...full LIBERTY
 

Silverseeker, you did an awsome job on that penny. I think I will give it a try. I dont think I could do it to an indianhead unless it looked as bad as the wheats I dig around here.
 

dugfinds said:
bscofield6 said:
I would loooooooooove to able to get rid of the green as well. It would make these 90 indian heads I dug this year worth some actual money. I got some pretty good dates in what I found, but sadly being green takes any significant collector value away from them.

Do you want to collect them or find them? If you want to collect them then buy them, If you want to find them then appreciate the patination.

Well it would be nice to be able to sell some of the finds. I'm not saying I want to collect them, I'm saying it would be nice if they weren't green so that if I ever wanted to sell some of my finds I could actually get some decent money for them.
 

What turns them green ? I have found Indians, but they all have been deep brown. Now wheat cents are another matter, they always seem to be corroded really bad, or green.
 

Gribnitz said:
What turns them green ? I have found Indians, but they all have been deep brown. Now wheat cents are another matter, they always seem to be corroded really bad, or green.

Soil conditions, water, weather, etc. That's my best answer, haha, sorry it's not too technical. All of the ones I find are green as are most old wheats.
 

I agree with everyone else, don't try to clean them, just be happy you can read the date. I think a little dirt left on the coin helps to read the date.

I also tell people not to try and clean 2 cent pieces, sheilded nickel's or V-nickel's, they turn to crap also. Most of the coins we dig are not going to earn you a lot of money. We just have fun finding them and enjoying them. If of course it is silver, well that's another story.

HH, Ringfinder
 

Don't clean them. Your efforts will not improve the collector's value of the coin. Well said, T.Stag.

Buckleboy
 

Ok, I think I may (may) have found something new. I have been trying an ultrasonic cleaner w/ regular solution, to no avail - but - last night I was soooo fed up (with approx 10 coins, unknown value @ the time, due to complete "incrustation"), that I changed solutions. 3 turned out to be mercury dimes, 5 - 1940's silver Canadian cents, and 2 1960' quarters! All look brand new now!

In the ultrasonic, I used "ZEP-Tub & Tile Cleaner" (Home Depot), for approx 20 minutes, on Hi.

P.S. Guys, I don't recommend using your girls ultrasonic cleaner (trust me, she will not like it!) :-\
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top