YOUR FAVORITE CLUE/EVIDENCE

alan m said:
That story was told in the book titled “The Killer Mountains”, I have tried to track down where Glen Magil or the writer Curt Gentry got the story but so far (a few years now) I have had no luck.
Click to expand...

It's very likely fictional, and also very likely something that Celeste Jones invented as an excuse to blow up Weaver's Needle which she was obsessed with. Perhaps that is why Dave's contact doesn't want to talk about it- because he realized he had been fooled into wasting his time with Jones.
 

alan m said:
Hello Wayne, will you share where you got the clue about a N-S line between four peaks and WN?
thanks in advance
Click to expand...

Unnamed Map.jpg

Is this the same thing?
 

alan m,

On page 15 of the Brownie Holmes manuscript Brownie states Waltz told his father, ..... go through the saddle and on up a low ridge, and when you get on the highest point of the ridge you can look north and the Four Peaks are lined up to look as one peak. In the other direction you will see a high needle, (pointed rock). In the canyon under you is my hidden camp.

That is word for word from the original copy of the Holmes manuscript (1944).

Matthew
 

alan m said:
Hello Wayne, will you share where you got the clue about a N-S line between four peaks and WN?
thanks in advance
Click to expand...

From the various sources of "clues".

You can see Weaver's Needle to the south and Four Peaks to the north where Four Peaks looks like one peak.

Go to First Water, then to Second Water, then take the old Government trail to San Carlos. Where the trail turns south, you will see over the point of the ridge, you can look north and the Four Peaks are lined up to look like one peak. In the other direction you will see a high needle-pointed rock. In the canyon under you is the hidden camp. You can't get down there because it is too steep, but go to the mouth of the canyon and then back. You can find the rock house with very little difficulty. You won't be able to see it until you are right upon it. After finding the camp, come back out of the canyon. Across the canyon and up it is a side canyon. Go up this side canyon to a cave. Opposite the cave is a tunnel and the mine.

20) One needs to climb up about 40 feet to see Weavers Needle to the south. (Waltz)

If I find any other examples, I'll add them to this post later.
 

Matthew Roberts said:
alan m,

On page 15 of the Brownie Holmes manuscript Brownie states Waltz told his father, ..... go through the saddle and on up a low ridge, and when you get on the highest point of the ridge you can look north and the Four Peaks are lined up to look as one peak. In the other direction you will see a high needle, (pointed rock). In the canyon under you is my hidden camp.

That is word for word from the original copy of the Holmes manuscript (1944).

Matthew
Click to expand...
Thank you Matthew, I do not put any faith in the Holmes manuscript, the fact that this clue is not possible to view anywhere within the Superstitions is one of the many reasons that I doubt the validity of the Holmes manuscript.
 

somehiker said:
From the various sources of "clues".

You can see Weaver's Needle to the south and Four Peaks to the north where Four Peaks looks like one peak.

Go to First Water, then to Second Water, then take the old Government trail to San Carlos. Where the trail turns south, you will see over the point of the ridge, you can look north and the Four Peaks are lined up to look like one peak. In the other direction you will see a high needle-pointed rock. In the canyon under you is the hidden camp. You can't get down there because it is too steep, but go to the mouth of the canyon and then back. You can find the rock house with very little difficulty. You won't be able to see it until you are right upon it. After finding the camp, come back out of the canyon. Across the canyon and up it is a side canyon. Go up this side canyon to a cave. Opposite the cave is a tunnel and the mine.

20) One needs to climb up about 40 feet to see Weavers Needle to the south. (Waltz)

If I find any other examples, I'll add them to this post later.
Click to expand...
Thank you Wayne, again, this is not possible, unless the “four peaks” are not THE Four Peaks.
 

alan m said:
Thank you Wayne, again, this is not possible, unless the “four peaks” are not THE Four Peaks.
Click to expand...

There is a place along a ridge line where both can be seen, with FP to the north and WN to the south, but not with either in their entirety.
The four peaks did not also have individual names in those days, so Waltz couldn't have named what he could see as anything else.
Or even the mountain he was on at the time.
 

Last edited:
alan m,

I fully understand your not believing the Holmes manuscript. Everyone must make that decision for themselves. I believe the part about 4 peaks looking as one because I have been on that ground and found things that fit with those directions. That is my findings and I don't expect anyone else to buy into what I've found or believe. We all have to do our reading and put boots on the ground to test out what we've read.

Best,

Matthew
 

Matthew Roberts said:
alan m,

I fully understand your not believing the Holmes manuscript. Everyone must make that decision for themselves. I believe the part about 4 peaks looking as one because I have been on that ground and found things that fit with those directions. That is my findings and I don't expect anyone else to buy into what I've found or believe. We all have to do our reading and put boots on the ground to test out what we've read.

Best,

Matthew
Click to expand...
Please understand that I am not trying to argue or be difficult, but I must ask, were the things you discovered related to the LDM?.
as you probably know, there are some who believe that Waltz found his gold West of the Superstitions, more around Goldfield, this area is the only one where the Four Peaks can be viewed as one, but I am sure that WN cannot be seen from there.
 

alan m said:
Please understand that I am not trying to argue or be difficult, but I must ask, were the things you discovered related to the LDM?.
as you probably know, there are some who believe that Waltz found his gold West of the Superstitions, more around Goldfield, this area is the only one where the Four Peaks can be viewed as one, but I am sure that WN cannot be seen from there.
Click to expand...
you can see wn from the goldfield area but not at goldfield...you have to go a little north by doc rosencrans claim to see it
 

azdave35 said:
you can see wn from the goldfield area but not at goldfield...you have to go a little north by doc rosencrans claim to see it
Click to expand...

But to the east, not to the south.
So too far away from a northward line towards Four Peaks.
A topo view showing the line area and 5mi radius by EEThr.
 

Attachments

  • EEThr map.jpg
    EEThr map.jpg
    74.5 KB · Views: 97
The 5 miles radius is wrong. Actually the clue says " a circle 5 miles in diameter with the WN in the center ".
So the radius should be 2,5 miles.
 

alan m said:
Thank you Wayne, again, this is not possible, unless the “four peaks” are not THE Four Peaks.
Click to expand...

Or the needle is not Weavers needle, I believe both are possibilities. I have some evidence that points me to believe both of the possibilities.
 

Matthew Roberts said:
alan m,

On page 15 of the Brownie Holmes manuscript Brownie states Waltz told his father, ..... go through the saddle and on up a low ridge, and when you get on the highest point of the ridge you can look north and the Four Peaks are lined up to look as one peak. In the other direction you will see a high needle, (pointed rock). In the canyon under you is my hidden camp.

That is word for word from the original copy of the Holmes manuscript (1944).

Matthew
Click to expand...
I believe this to be fact about 4 Peaks. I do not have a pic, but have seen it.

Edit: Matthew, thanks for posting this from the manuscript. Pretty specific directions, once at the saddle.
Sincerely, Idaho Dutch
 

Last edited:
4-Peaks as 1 and the Saddle

Matthew Roberts said:
alan m,

On page 15 of the Brownie Holmes manuscript Brownie states Waltz told his father, ..... go through the saddle and on up a low ridge, and when you get on the highest point of the ridge you can look north and the Four Peaks are lined up to look as one peak. In the other direction you will see a high needle, (pointed rock). In the canyon under you is my hidden camp.

That is word for word from the original copy of the Holmes manuscript (1944).

Matthew
Click to expand...

At the upper left of the ravine that is represented below sure looks like it fits the description of the saddle, and I can confirm that hiking from that saddle to the high point of the south ridge of the ravine is where I saw 4-peaks as 1. (edit - at the high point) :)
The Ravine.jpg

Sincerely, Idaho
 

Last edited:
somehiker said:
There is a place along a ridge line where both can be seen, with FP to the north and WN to the south, but not with either in their entirety.
The four peaks did not also have individual names in those days, so Waltz couldn't have named what he could see as anything else.
Or even the mountain he was on at the time.
Click to expand...

somehiker,
The ridgeline you speak of . . . North end of Black Top Mesa . . . just before it drops down into Needle Canyon to the North. . .
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

ERNIE PROVENCE

⬅️ Previous Thread

FIND THE STARTER DRILL HOLE ON THE STONE MAPS?

Next Thread ➡️

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Steve's Detector Rods

Latest Discussions

Back
Top