The powers that be here should think about taking the time to maybe write these cruise lines
stating that we have over 100,000 members here and they are going to lose tourists
by banning the traveling with detectors on their ships
When i wrote for a magazine yrs ago i wrote 3 cruise lines like 15 yrs ago and said i was the
president of a large detecting org. with 1000s of members - I received nice official
letters from all 3 saying that most times it was 1 person that took it upon themself to ban
it and it was not their normal policy - i posted the replys here loooong ago
I got balls busted by some guy at airport yrs ago - he said it was illegal - i made a scene
got heads involved made him look like a fool - almost missed my flight - it was HIS rule
not the airlines
Good grief, what possible reason could a person have at the cruise lines where they would take it upon themselves to ban metal detectors, sounds like a personal issue. Maybe they used to have one, never found anything, so they don't want anyone else to be able to find what they couldn't. Or maybe they really wanted one as a kid, but their mommy didn't buy them one, so they're psychologically soured on metal detectors in general, lol.
But I'll give the cruise lines the benefit of the doubt. They may just be following the rules/laws of the countries they're heading to. So, for instance, if Jamica has banned metal detectors and one of their ships will be heading to Jamica, I can see where they would add metal detectors to the list of prohibited items for that Cruise. I'm sure they don't want to be the "bad guy" and have to confiscate one of their guests' detectors, which would probably cause a big scene and would create bad blood between the guest and the cruise lines, where it wasn't the cruise lines rule, it was the rule of the country the ship was heading to. To me, that makes sense, and I could see that as a possible explanation.
That said, prohibiting metal detectors for the cruise to Jamaica should only be listed for that specific cruise to Jamaica. Or if another ship is traveling to another country where detectors are banned, then it should only be on the prohibited list for that specific cruise. But if the ship is heading to Cozumel and detectors aren't banned in Cozumel, it shouldn't be on the prohibited list for that specific cruise, if detectors are indeed allowed at the destination they'll be sailing to.
Sidenote: Many years ago, I & the ex-went with a bunch of our friends, 20 of us in total, on a Carnival Cruise to Belize, Cozumel and I think there was another location included. I really liked Carnival, there was so much to do on that ship, and I was never bored. While we were in Cozumel, Hurricane Dennis was active and approaching, so we had to hang tight and stay for many extra hours, until the Captain could see where the Hurricane was heading. Once they saw that it had veered and started heading to Florida, we took off and followed the Hurrican back to Tampa. The Hurricane was about 100 miles ahead of us and the trip was pretty rowdy, with huge waves and strong winds, but that was pretty cool IMO, as I just love bad weather. But as we got closer to FL, the weather calmed down and the trip became very enjoyable. I was sitting on the deck with a bunch of my friends, there was a nice breeze, had a drink in my hand, and we were really enjoying our last couple of hours before docking in Tampa.
About an hour before we were scheduled to dock, a voice came over the loudspeaker, asking everyone that bought and would be taking back bottles of liquor to line up at a specific place on the ship for Customs. OK, no problem, so I grabbed my box of liquor that I bought, went to where they said we needed to go, and stood in line with everyone else. And I stood, and stood, and stood. It was getting really hot where we were standing and we're all wondering where the Customs guy was, as the line wasn't moving. I stood in that line for an hour, sweating as it was hot. Finally, someone told me that the Customs guy isn't on the ship, he's at the dock and won't be on the ship until we arrived in Tampa. WTF!!!! You mean I've been standing in line sweating, for the last hour and the Customs guy isn't even on the ship?
I could have spent that last hour on the deck with my friends, continuing to enjoy our drinks and the nice cool breeze, it was my last hour on the ship, and it was wasted by standing in line for Customs, who wouldn't be boarding until we docked in Tampa. Once we docked, the Customs guy came on, walked past me to go into a room on the ship where he'd be checking everything out, and just as he passed by me, he stopped and yelled out to everyone that if we had less than x number of bottles of liquor, we didn't need to go through Customs. WTF again!!!!
I had less than the number of bottles he mentioned so I didn't even have to check them through Customs. Don't know if this was miscommunication or what, but I spent the last hour of a cruise I really enjoyed being totally pissed off, and that last hour sweating in line, when I didn't even need to be there and that really ruined the trip for me. Man, I was really, really pissed and steam must have been coming out my ears. But now I know for the next cruise, if I ever hear that announcement again, I'm staying put. I'll wait until we dock before I get up to check anything I bought through customs, so lesson learned. But just goes to show how 1 simple miscommunication can really spoil an otherwise great cruise.