beach water hunting

gulfrebinms

Jr. Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2013
Messages
53
Reaction score
9
Golden Thread
0
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Never heard of it where I hunt in Fl panhandle. I've hunted up to neck deep water and never had any problem.
 

reply

i was talking to a guy detecting on the beach in fairhope alabama today and he said you couldnt hunt in the water in gulf or there said that the state said anything over 50 years old belonged to the state,they messing up everything for detectorist anyone know about this

Then my question to this guy you met would be : "who told you that?". And if he simply says he heard it from someone else (or read it on a forum or whatever), then I would regress back further as to where THAT info came from.

The same "50 yr." thing could probably be said of state-of-CA beaches (and I suppose all the states, fed, etc...) if you asked long enough and hard enough of enough lawyers and archies. It's buried in minutia about cultural heritage. But if Alabama is anything like CA, then you have nothing to worry about. We hunt state of CA beaches here all the time (yup, in and out of the water), and (gasp) find coins over 50 yrs. old. Especially after storm erosion washes out/erodes sand down to the old coins. No one's ever cared, and it's always just been considered ok, despite what a literal reading reads, and despite what some lone archie might claim. Moral of the story ? Don't ask silly questions. My hunch is, whomever you talked to is worrying too much, and asking silly questions, or reading answers of people who asked silly questions before him.
 

it is up to you to know the regulations that govern your hunting area.

As for people you meet on the beach there are three types

1. non hunter locals who don't want you there

2. Hunter locals who don't want you there

3. helpful vets of the hobby.

read that and understand that there is really no way of knowing which of the three you are talking to. But, know that the odds of someone looking out for your best interests are stacked against you.

Lastly, Fl is the only state i know of with laws limiting water hunting. And, those laws only pertain to one area.
 

Besides the 50 year law but who cares if I scoop a wheat penny anyway?

diggummup, you've been hunting for many years, right? Ok then, you tell me: When was the last time you ever had someone follow you around with a calculator, doing the math on the ages of coins you found ANYWAYS ? I've been hunting for over 35 yrs, and have YET to see anyone following me around, or riffling through my apron at the end of the day, doing the math on ages of coins I found. I mean, sheesk, if it's *really* that big of a deal for anyone that (gasp), they might find a coin older than 50 years, then for pete's sake, put *those* coins in your *other* pocket.

Heck, I probably could get a 51 yr. old coin in change when I go to 7-11 later today and buy that slurpee I plan on buying.
 

Aren't coins considered legal tender? I don't think there are any laws against using a coin over fifty years old. How could it be illegal to find one over fifty years old?
 

reply

Aren't coins considered legal tender? I don't think there are any laws against using a coin over fifty years old. How could it be illegal to find one over fifty years old?

Tommy, well think of it: It's not out-of the realm of possibility to get a memorial penny in your change, dated 1962 or earlier. Afterall, no one collects memorials, so pennies from the '60s are still in circulation. Same for jefferson nickels: no one collects jeffersons, unless they are war nickels, right? So it's entirely possible to get an early '60s, even 1950s jefferson in your change, right? Heck, it's even possible to get a silver coin in your change I suppose :)

So let's say you went out to some supposed high-brow site, where supposedly "cultural heritage" verbage existed. If you dropped one of those coins (like when you were fumbling for your keys to get in your car), and then you stooped over, to pick up that 51 yr. old penny, ..... would you be in violation of any law ? :laughing7: :tongue3: :tongue3: :icon_scratch:

I think I'll go ask the next "purist" archaeologist I see. Afterall, you "can't be too safe", right? I "wouldn't want to get arrested" right? It "doesn't hurt to ask", right? haha

And yes you're right: all coins minted are all legal tender. So technically there's nothing to stop you from taking silver dollars, seated quarters, large cents, silver dimes, etc... and going and spending them. I know a gal who worked at a fast food place, during when she was in high school in the 1970s. She said that one day, a guy came in and bought food using silver dollars! And some halves, etc... She accepted the payment (after doing a "double-take" to realize/see that they were USA coins). Then she promptly took them out of the register when the customer had left, and exchanged them for modern money and paper bills out of her own pocket. She surmised the guy had stolen them (because he looked like a bum or addict or something).
 

Last edited:
Oops! I found a 1918 wheat Penny yesterday and showed to my wife!
Now my conspiratorial wife and I will turn ourselves in!:laughing7:
 

Aren't coins considered legal tender? I don't think there are any laws against using a coin over fifty years old. How could it be illegal to find one over fifty years old?
It's not unless you dig it up in the water off a Fl. beach or one of the other states that has the law, technically speaking of course. The law states that anything over 50 years old must be reported and turned over to the state. Ridiculous... yes.

diggummup, you've been hunting for many years, right? Ok then, you tell me: When was the last time you ever had someone follow you around with a calculator, doing the math on the ages of coins you found ANYWAYS ?
Never, I just wonder what brilliant bureaucrat came up with the magic number of 50. Stupid.
 

thank all of you for the answers
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom