Cut 8 real counterfeit ?

Eastcoasthunter21

Bronze Member
Feb 24, 2015
1,154
2,555
New York/Florida
🥇 Banner finds
2
Detector(s) used
DEUS ALL THE WAY
Primary Interest:
Metal Detecting
Hello everybody I got out today with two thirds of The ba$terd$ of bramble Steve is been on a hot streak on his own and had daddy duty today
so bart and I got out we went to a spot that was good to us in the spring and now that all the brambles died off we were able to get deeper into the woods together we had a great day
We pulled four coppers Bart pulled early 1900s Silver and I pulled a cut eight Reale
It's a carlos the third somewhere between 1785 and 1789 but after cleaning and photos I believe it's a fake I showed Steve and bart and we seem to agree that it's a fake
Thank you for reading happy hunting and good luck
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1039.JPG
    IMG_1039.JPG
    536.5 KB · Views: 145
  • IMG_1043.JPG
    IMG_1043.JPG
    745.3 KB · Views: 136
  • IMG_1042.JPG
    IMG_1042.JPG
    805 KB · Views: 147
  • IMG_1041.JPG
    IMG_1041.JPG
    664.5 KB · Views: 137
  • IMG_1040.JPG
    IMG_1040.JPG
    663.7 KB · Views: 142
Upvote 12
Hello everybody I got out today with two thirds of The ba$terd$ of bramble Steve is been on a hot streak on his own and had daddy duty today
so bart and I got out we went to a spot that was good to us in the spring and now that all the brambles died off we were able to get deeper into the woods together we had a great day
We pulled four coppers Bart pulled early 1900s Silver and I pulled a cut eight Reale
It's a carlos the third somewhere between 1785 and 1789 but after cleaning and photos I believe it's a fake I showed Steve and bart and we seem to agree that it's a fake
Thank you for reading happy hunting and good luck

Great day indeed Charlie! I was only able to ID one of the 3 LC's: 1832 the others will go into the mystery green disc box :)

That Cut 8 is something, regardless! Being a counterfeit might make it more rare!

Great digs bud!
 

Looks like a fake to me but thats just as cool a piece of history as the real deal.
 

Well you know my feeling about the coin C-Dawg, but I can't wait to hear from some experts.

Awesome find. Best example I've personally seen! Wow.
 

Very cool find, looks like it took a few hits to cut it in half- so there must be the other half lurking around in the brambles.
 

Doesn't look regal, but awful damn cool! Well done
 

I bet you've been waiting to type "it is not a real real" Charlie. :tongue3: That's a sweet find, being counterfeit or not. :icon_thumright:
 

Like I told you last night, that is an awesome find. It was made to deceive people! I think that makes it all the better.

Best of luck to you Charlie!
 

real or counterfeit, take one of those either way. congrats!!!!
 

Killer counterfeit Charlie! That is some thick plating on that thing. I think I see chisel marks on the obverse... I bet someone when to make some change with their chisel, found out it was fake, cursed and chucked it!
 

Yeap, had one myself, its the closest I've come to an 8!
 

I'd be tickled pink with that counterfeit 8. Next best thing to the reale thing, lol.
 

Any silver looking coin that is broken I tend to suspect is counterfeit, and it certainly looks that way with the picture of the edge. I'd really love to find a crude struck one... but it's rare!
 

Any silver looking coin that is broken I tend to suspect is counterfeit, and it certainly looks that way with the picture of the edge. I'd really love to find a crude struck one... but it's rare!

When I dug it I sent scrappy a photo he sdid
The same thing it looked broken not clean cut Thanks for looking.
 

Sweet find and counterfeit would only make it that much Sweeter for me.
Congrats!!
 

When I dug it I sent scrappy a photo he sdid
The same thing it looked broken not clean cut Thanks for looking.


I would expect if a silver coin was broken, it would also have a severe bend, it wouldn't just snap in two.
 

Man, that is a cool find! Great job! Something else to add to the bucket list, right next to a real real ( I got to use it too) which I'm still searching for!
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top