I keep all 1959 and below nickels, when I have too many of the nickels dated between 1955-1959, I only keep the decant ones and throw the lesser grade ones back. It doesn't matter what shape the coin is, I keep all nickels 1954 and older.
Just to point out, some people are very rude on this forum with spelling... it is not dollors, daullaurs, doughlars, dollhairs, or anything like that.
Just for further notice, before you go to post your messages, a useful thing 2 tabs to the right of the post icon is a spell check button. This will correct your spelling errors and rude people on here won't mock.
People just have to be arrogant and have nothing else better to do with their lives other than to pounce on someones mistake and make a big dean about it.
Hope this helps, and keep up the CRH'ing! You're doing very well!
-BuffaloBoy
