Has anyone read "Hidden Treasures of the Black Range The Real Story of the Lost Adams Diggings" by Marshall Bulle?

Steamboat

Jr. Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2018
Messages
74
Reaction score
177
Golden Thread
0
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
This book published in 2015 claims to have found the lost Adams diggings. It has lots of pictures, maps, etc. According to this book the Adams diggings were not gold nuggets found in a stream bead, but a Spanish Gold mine.
I am not an expert in this area, and would like to hear what those of you who have done a lot of research on this subject think of this book and it's conclusions.
 

This search was originally for an alleged 1600's Spanish cannon (or two) near the top or possibly just down on the east slope of the Black Range. Those early field cannons were small, about 40 inches. Here's one recovered in Arizona, alleged to have been abandoned by the Coronado Expedition.
Coronado cannon.png

Coronado Cannon recovery, 2020

Being small and light, it is plausible that small field cannons like these could have found their way up to the top of the Black Range. It's feasible that the revolting Natives recovered them from the fleeing Spanish in 1680 at the east bottom of the range, somewhere on the Camino Real as they driving the invaders back to El Paso. It would have been in character for the Natives to haul them up and hide them where they would not likely be recovered. Makes sense to me anyway. So, the cannon story, for me, is a definite possibility.

However, there is no record of gold being recovered anywhere near where the cannons were allegedly recovered in the Black Range, and rumors of a Spanish gold mine up in that vicinity require quite a leap of faith. To my knowledge, no indications of a mine was found while searching for the cannons, but anything's possible, I suppose. But, conflating those ideas to the Adams Diggings is wholly contradictory to the numerous versions of the LAD tale, all of which verify the recovery was placer gold, not lode.

Here's a great video from Ty Lee, who visits the alleged cannon recovery site from the east side of the ridge on horseback and on foot. The Black Range is difficult and rugged, as you'll see if you watch the video. Awesome work, Ty.
 

Well, I finished the book. It is like so many others who claim to have found the Lost Adams diggings, they didn't find the gold.
They claim the gold wasn't in a stream bed but was from a Spanish mine.
Do gold nuggets come from a mine or do they come from a stream bed?
Here is a quote from pg. 229. "As we have said many times, we were never after the gold. the mine is likely somewhere near or up above where those marker rocks (Shown on pg. 226) are located. We could never tell the story and go after the gold at the same time, so we chose the story."
Does that make sense to anyone?
 

Well, I finished the book. It is like so many others who claim to have found the Lost Adams diggings, they didn't find the gold.
They claim the gold wasn't in a stream bed but was from a Spanish mine.
Do gold nuggets come from a mine or do they come from a stream bed?
Here is a quote from pg. 229. "As we have said many times, we were never after the gold. the mine is likely somewhere near or up above where those marker rocks (Shown on pg. 226) are located. We could never tell the story and go after the gold at the same time, so we chose the story."
Does that make sense to anyone?
"Take the gold; leave the story."

Although the story is so much better if first the author finds the gold...

Good luck to all,

The Old Bookaroo
 

Here is a quote from pg. 229. "As we have said many times, we were never after the gold. the mine is likely somewhere near or up above where those marker rocks (Shown on pg. 226) are located. We could never tell the story and go after the gold at the same time, so we chose the story."
LMAO, Mel Fisher found the gold and got someone else to write the durn book while he counted the gold.
 

. . .
Here is a quote from pg. 229. "As we have said many times, we were never after the gold. the mine is likely somewhere near or up above where those marker rocks (Shown on pg. 226) are located. We could never tell the story and go after the gold at the same time, so we chose the story."
Does that make sense to anyone?
No.
 

Well, I finished the book. It is like so many others who claim to have found the Lost Adams diggings, they didn't find the gold.
They claim the gold wasn't in a stream bed but was from a Spanish mine.
Do gold nuggets come from a mine or do they come from a stream bed?
Here is a quote from pg. 229. "As we have said many times, we were never after the gold. the mine is likely somewhere near or up above where those marker rocks (Shown on pg. 226) are located. We could never tell the story and go after the gold at the same time, so we chose the story."
Does that make sense to anyone?

IMHO, the abundance of gold nuggets described by Adams in his story, is not possible to be provided by only one gold outcropping. There should be few more gold outcroppings along that main canyon, or coming from different tributaries along its route. To me, a specific canyon in the Superstitions Arizona, would be the possible candidate to match Adams story.
In the most cases, people who are interested to verify treasure stories, are searching in the wrong place, not because they are not understand the clues, but because the clues are somehow not accurate as a result of the story teller's partial confusion. The most mountain ranges in the SW were not surveyed at all in the 1860's. Wilderness everywhere, except few colonial mines here and there. Only Natives knew almost all the turns and the richies in the mountains.
 

Last edited:
I know where the 2 mountain caps that look like sugar loaves are... I noticed them before I had ever heard of the "Adam's Diggings". They made that much of an impression on me. At the the time I had seen them, I didn't know the shape of a sugar loaf either. Some years later got to talking and read the story. The main marker used in for guiding the men to their destination was the two mountain tops that look like sugar loaves, where at the base of that mountain, is the zig-zag canyon that only allows single file on horseback. to a boulder that hides the entrance. I know where the 2 sugar loaf mountain peaks are located.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom