ID help

outlawatheart · Dec 22, 2013

View attachment 916266 View attachment 916267

Would like to know what type these are, I posted the white one before. The new one was found in the same area. They both have that double wing thing going on.

outlawatheart · Dec 22, 2013

here's the new one it wouldn't post for some reason

monsterrack · Dec 22, 2013

Is the base broken off the second one and is there any light base grinding on the other, and where did they come from.

Rege-PA · Dec 22, 2013

The first one appears to be an "Evans" late archaic to woodland. The second could have been a salvaged point that broke at the base and was rehafted, need better picture of base. Nice finds.

outlawatheart · Dec 22, 2013

the base IS broken. no grinding visible on the little one. Both are southern Illinois finds

monsterrack said:
Is the base broken off the second one and is there any light base grinding on the other, and where did they come from.

monsterrack · Dec 22, 2013

This is JMO. This one is hard to ID, I don't think it is a Evans it looks more like a Sinner point, they both are the same time period, but the problem with both types are they are La. points mostly, I will do some more research and get back to you on this one.

Rege-PA · Dec 22, 2013

"Evans" point distribution can extend into the midwest, although I don`t know how common they are.

monsterrack · Dec 22, 2013

I agree all points go out into much wider ranges, and this is JMO look at photos Evans at the top, Sinner in the middle. That's why I say Sinner, but it could be neither one who knows, only the man that made them and I bet he did not call them nothing but something to get supper with.View attachment 916753

outlawatheart · Dec 23, 2013

It does look right MR...THNX.

monsterrack said:
I agree all points go out into much wider ranges, and this is JMO look at photos Evans at the top, Sinner in the middle. That's why I say Sinner, but it could be neither one who knows, only the man that made them and I bet he did not call them nothing but something to get supper with.View attachment 916753