Sorry, but some misinformation needs to be corrected here:
...Most iron meteorites are slightly magnetic and do show up as iron on a display...
ALL iron meteorites are
strongly attracted to a magnet since their majority or second-largest component is native iron.
... The really rare ones contain nickel and cannot be detect, albeit attracted to a magnet...
Iron meteorites containing nickel are not “really rare ones”. As said above, all iron meteorites contain at least some nickel… typically in the region of 6% - 20% with some outliers a little above and below those values. There is a rare class of iron meteorites known as ataxites that can have an exceptionally high nickel content up to about 65%, but the remainder is still predominantly iron, so even higher-nickel ataxites are still strongly attracted to a magnet.
I have several I found by looks alone, as nickel ones often show signs of being melted.
Melt features in iron meteorites have nothing whatsoever to do with the presence of nickel. The two metals have similar melting points (Iron: 1,538 °C; Nickel: 1,453 °C) but, in any case, the two metals are present as the nickel-iron alloys kamacite (melting point 1,450°C to 1,500°C) and/or taenite (melting point 1,450°C to 1,500°C).
Neither alloy has a fixed composition, with kamacite containing 5% to 7.5% nickel by weight, and taenite containing 20% to 65% nickel by weight. Ataxites are composed primarily of taenite… hence the higher nickel content.
Depending on their size, all meteorites bring good money.
That’s a bit of a generalisation. Meteorite values vary enormously according to classification and the extent of the fall. Some iron meteorites which already have a formal name and a large strewnfield start as little as 50 cents per gram (as do unclassified Saharan chondrites); stony Lunar or Martian meteorites can go up into the thousands per gram. New falls tend to have the highest values, but those are generally only realised if the meteorite has been submitted for formal classification by an appropriately qualified laboratory and accepted into the MetSoc database.